harrylin
- 3,874
- 93
Good - although it isn't exactly a citation, that is in fact what I had in mind.PAllen said:General covariance = all coordinates are equally good, and none are physical per se (they are conventions). Any may equally be used to make predictions = compute invariants; invariants are coordinate independent. Einstein several times regretted that relativity wasn't called the theory of invariants instead.
General covariance was a key founding principle for Einstein, along with equivalence principle. In response to a critique by Kretschmann, he admitted it has little force a 'selector of valid theories'. But he never let go of as principle of GR, and nor does modern GR.
Once more, compare:
all coordinates are equally good, and none are physical per se (they are conventions)
with
"the time parameter t [..] is not suited to describe the physical problem at hand"
For me it is a consistency requirement for a theory that all valid coordinate systems make the same predictions; both system should make the same predictions.