Partial Differential Equation in Special Relativity

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around demonstrating how the wave equation for light waves, expressed as u_tt - c^2u_xx, transforms under a change of coordinates. Participants worked through the derivatives u_xx and u_tt, ultimately finding that u_tt - c^2u_xx can be expressed in terms of new coordinates but does not satisfy the same wave equation. The key point is that if u satisfies the wave equation in the original coordinates (x, t), it will not satisfy it in the transformed coordinates (x', t'). This conclusion arises from the mathematical evaluation of the two expressions, which are shown to be unequal. The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding coordinate transformations in the context of special relativity.
Nerrad
Messages
20
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


(a) Light waves satisfy the wave equation ##u_{tt}-c^2u_{xx}## where ##c## is the speed of light.
Consider change of coordinates $$x'=x-Vt$$ $$t'=t$$
where V is a constant. Use the chain rule to show that ##u_x=u_{x'}## and ##u_{tt}=-Vu_{x'}+u_{t'}##
Find ##u_{xx},u_{tt},## and hence ##u_{tt}-c^2u_{xx}##, in terms of derivatives with respect to ##x'## and ##t'##.
Deduce that if ##u## satisfies the wave equation in ##x,t## coordinates, then it does not satisfy the same equation in the ##x',t'## coordinates.

The Attempt at a Solution


So I've worked out that $$u_{xx}=u_{x'x'}$$ and $$u_{tt}=u_{t't'}+v^2(u_{x'x'})-2v(u_{x'xt})$$ so technically ##u_{tt}-c^2u_{xx}## expressed in terms of derivatives with respect to ##x'## and ##t'## would just be $$u_{t't'}+v^2(u_{x'x'})-2v(u_{x'xt})-c^2(u_{x'x'})=0$$ right?
But how do I do the bit where question says "Deduce that if ##u## satisfies the wave equation in ##x,t## coordinates, then it does not satisfy the same equation in the ##x',t'## coordinates." I don't know where to start with this?Would this be done conceptually or mathematically?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Nerrad said:
I don't know where to start with this?
Start with the wave equation.
 
kuruman said:
Start with the wave equation.
Can you give a little bit more hints than that please? Thanks
 
I give up. Can you guide me through this. Please. Thanks
 
Last edited:
Is it simply due to the fact that ##u_{xx}-c^2u_{tt} \neq u_{x'x'}-c^2u_{t't'} ##, so that if ##u## satisfies the wave equation in ##x##,##t## coordinates, then it does not satisfy the same equation in the ##x'##,##t'## coordinates? Or do I deduce it mathematically?
 
If you calculate ##u_{xx}-c^2u_{tt}## and ##u_{x'x'}-c^2u_{t't'}## and it turns out that the two expressions are not equal, then you have "deduced it mathematically."
 
  • Like
Likes Nerrad
Back
Top