Schools Physics REUs 2016: Applying & Updates

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around applicants sharing their experiences and updates regarding their applications to various research programs, particularly in astronomy and physics. Many participants report rejections from prestigious institutions like Duke, SAO, and UCLA, with acceptance rates highlighted for context. Several individuals are still awaiting responses from multiple programs, expressing anxiety about the lengthy decision process. Some have received updates indicating they are waitlisted or have been accepted into other programs, such as LSU and Columbia. Participants discuss the importance of following up with program coordinators for updates and share advice on handling interviews and managing expectations. The conversation reflects a mix of hope and frustration as applicants navigate the competitive landscape of research opportunities.
Finesagan
Messages
7
Reaction score
3
How's everyone doing? Also, anyone hear back from the schools they applied to?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Rejected from DUKE/TUNL on Feb. 26th; they said they had 313 application for 12 slots, that's 3.8% acceptance.

Haven't heard back from:
SULI // Lehigh Univ. // CU Boulder // Nevis Labs // Vanderbilt // Baylor // Texas A&M // Northwestern // Purdue // SETI // SAO // William&Mary // UC Davis // Notre Dame // U Michigan //
 
SAO Rejection 3/1. No word on number of applicants, etc.

Does anyone else have information?
 
Rejected from UM CERN on Febuary 15 (they had 235 applications), and SAO 3/1.
no word from:
  • Northwestern
  • Haystack
  • Rutgers
  • UC Davis
  • Madison
  • Rochester
  • Maryland
  • UWRF
  • UCLA
  • BU
  • Maria Mitchel
  • AO Puerto Rico
  • NSO Arizona
  • Cornell
 
Last edited:
Rutgers sent out an email today saying that they sent out acceptance letters
 
I don't know if I should be excited or not that two people say they got rejections from SAO yesterday, because I haven't heard anything from them as of now. (Maybe I'm on a waitlist?)

I only applied to a short list of astronomy programs (I have research opportunities at my home institution so it's not the end of the world if I don't get in), and astro programs have an informal agreement to not start releasing results until March 1st, but for the record no word from any of:

SAO
SETI Insititute
STScI
MMO
UWyo
 
As an update, I was rejected from Duke but accepted to LSU's REU program. I haven't heard anything else.
 
I emailed CU Boulder, they responded saying they had sent out acceptance emails already, and their Summer 2016 program is full.
 
I am still waiting to hear back from all of mine as well:

-SAO
-MIT Haystack (I had an interview, but didn't hear back)
-UMinnesota
-UMichigan
-AMHN
-Cornell
-LIGO
-Northwestern
 
  • #10
I just talked to the REU administrator at Indiana Bloomington. He said they are a little behind on the applications this year, but they will start reviewing them this week.
 
  • Like
Likes yeshuamo
  • #11
I know Northwestern has already sent out acceptances (I didn't apply, but like 4 people at my school got in, plus 1 freshman waitlisted). Also UMissouri sent out acceptances (a friend got in).
I'm still waiting to hear back from:
UMinnesota
University of South Florida
Georgia Tech (pretty sure I won't get in, I think I messed up on the personal statement)
LSU
UChicago
UNL

I think that's all I applied for...
 
  • #12
Update: Rejection from STScI (they got over 500 applications this year!), still no word elsewhere.
 
  • #13
I see one person had heard from Duke. I haven't heard back anything from them, yet, rejection or otherwise. Has anyone else received word from Duke on any level?

EDIT: Rejected from Duke. The e-mail filtered itself into my junk folder for some reason.

The only other institution I have heard from is USF, whom is scheduling phone interviews.
 
Last edited:
  • #14
TAMU - Cyclotron Institute Rejection 3/4
 
  • #15
I haven't heard back from SULI. I don't think I got in this year.
 
  • #16
Has anyone received letters from :
Notre Dame
Penn State
Vanderbilt
Purdue
LeHigh?
I have not received a denial or acceptance on any of these. Is it bad if you don't hear anything for this long..
 
Last edited:
  • #17
Updates on my 5 for any astro people who care:

SAO - Waitlisted. First round offers had until today to accept, I got a call this morning that I moved off the waitlist and they want a response within 24 hours. (If you haven't heard by end of week, assume "no".)
SETI Insititute - No word, no response to inquiry
STScI - Rejected, over 500 applications
MMO - No word, no response to inquiry
UWyo - Waitlisted, no estimate for how long that might stick around.
 
  • #18
rangerazlm said:
Has anyone received letters from :
Notre Dame
Penn State
Vanderbilt
Purdue
LeHigh?
I have not received a denail or acceptance on any of these. Is it bad if you don't hear anything for this long..

LeHigh had their deadline like the first of march they should have first offers by the end of the month. I know Penn state made first round offers because I received one but had a better offer, last year I also got an offer from them by the 16th of march but I had personal reasons for not attending. You should not worry yet especially when the deadlines have just passed, some programs get a lot of applications and take a while to review them all. You can always email the program coordinator and ask for information they are usually very nice and helpful
 
  • #19
szimmy said:
ut had a better offer, last year I also got an offer from them by the 16th of march but I had personal reasons for not attending. You should not worry yet especially
The wait is incredibly stressful. Especially as a Junior. This is my last chance:/
 
  • #20
Northwestern CIERA Rejection 3/9 - 477 applications for 7 positions, that is 1.46% acceptance.
 
  • #21
Notre Dame Rejection 3/9 - 270 applications for 14 positions; 5.18% acceptance.
 
  • #22
Vanderbilt is on Spring break as of 3/9; they intend to send acceptances/rejections early next week, and fill all spaces within the next two weeks.
 
  • #23
Well Minnesota said that they're canceling the REU.. how that's possible, I don't know..
 
  • #24
Rejection from ND 14 selected from 270 applications. ~5% acceptance
 
  • #25
Soap said:
Northwestern CIERA Rejection 3/9 - 477 applications for 7 positions, that is 1.46% acceptance.
4 of the acceptances were from my school (not me, I didn't apply). Sorry, I think they're looking in the Chicago area mostly, that's what I heard.
 
  • #26
Haven't heard back from a couple yet (including SULIs). But so far:

Cornell CLASSE (accelerator physics) - acceptance (12 positions, 215 applicants)
UCLA (plasma physics) - rejection (12 positions, >400 applicants)
LIGO - acceptance at Washington site (declined)
Nevis Labs - acceptance, includes some work at Fermilab
MIT MPC/CMSE - rejection (11 positions, 150 applicants)

Having trouble deciding between Nevis and Cornell.
 
Last edited:
  • #27
Update for astro people:

MIT Haystack - Accepted
Northwestern CIERA - Rejected
UofMinnesota - program was cancelled
SAO - Rejected

No word on:
UofMichigan
Cornell
AMNH
LIGO
 
  • #28
William and Mary Rejection 3/14/16
 
  • #29
University of Nebraska -Lincoln Acceptance 03/14
 
  • #30
Still haven't heard from:

Baylor
Kansas
Vanderbilt
 
  • #31
I was fortunate that my first acceptance came from my top choice. They give you one week to decide!

MIT Haystack -- accepted 3/1, offer accepted - 11 positions out of ~200
Chicago Physics -- accepted 3/15, offer declined - 24 positions total out of unknown # of applicants
NASA Goddard -- informal phone offer in January, offer declined - applied directly to the department, so 1 out of 1 as far as I know

Keck Northeastern consortium
Boston University Magnetic Fields
American Museum of Natural History
National Solar Observatory
 
Last edited:
  • #32
halebopp5294 said:
Update for astro people:

MIT Haystack - Accepted

Kudos!
 
  • #33
Decided to take Columbia. Good luck to those waiting on CLASSE.
 
  • #34
Anyone heard back from U of M or UCLA yet?
 
  • #35
Ramor said:
Anyone heard back from U of M or UCLA yet?
Yes. It seems UCLA has already filled their spots. There were 12 chosen out of 400 applicants.
 
  • #36
Finesagan said:
Yes. It seems UCLA have already filled their spots. There were 12 chosen out of 400 applicants.
do you know what the date was when they filled them?
 
  • #37
Vanderbilt said my app is in final selection. Said they are waiting on NSF grant info before any offers can be made. what exactly does this mean?
 
  • #38
rangerazlm said:
Vanderbilt said my app is in final selection. Said they are waiting on NSF grant info before any offers can be made. what exactly does this mean?
How did you hear this? Did they email you or did you ask them about the status?
 
  • #39
I asked about the status
 
  • #40
rangerazlm said:
I asked about the status
Okay, thanks. It just means that they need to ensure that the NSF will give them the money for your REU before they can send out offers.
 
  • #41
But what exactly does "final selection" likely refer to?
 
  • #42
Should I be worried that I applied to four REUs and haven't heard back from any? Has anyone heard from UC Davis, University of Michigan, TREND (University of Maryland), or Georgia Tech?

I know Georgia Tech extended their application deadline a couple times, so they might not have their decisions until later.
 
  • #43
idkidk1212 said:
Should I be worried that I applied to four REUs and haven't heard back from any? Has anyone heard from UC Davis, University of Michigan, TREND (University of Maryland), or Georgia Tech?

I know Georgia Tech extended their application deadline a couple times, so they might not have their decisions until later.
Email them
 
  • #44
rangerazlm said:
Email them
I've thought about it, but I didn't know if it would make me seem impatient. You think they wouldn't have a problem with it?
 
  • #45
No, they have coordinators to do exactly that. Email people.
 
  • #46
I received an email yesterday from UC Davis asking if I am interested in an offer from them.
 
  • #47
Waiting to hear from UC Davis, CU Boulder, UWashington, MSU, Vanderbilt, Lehigh...
Plus the IBM internship, don't know if anyone else on here applied to that.
 
  • #48
idkidk1212 said:
Should I be worried that I applied to four REUs and haven't heard back from any? Has anyone heard from UC Davis, University of Michigan, TREND (University of Maryland), or Georgia Tech?

I know Georgia Tech extended their application deadline a couple times, so they might not have their decisions until later.
To add to the "email them" comment, the faculty member who runs the REU at my school said that it's generally a good idea to phrase the email along the lines of:

"You are my first choice for an REU. Please tell me when I can hear about your decision so that I can make plans for any offers I get from other REUs. Ideally, I would love to accept yours."

In your own, more courteous, words, of course.
 
  • Like
Likes Jody
  • #49
yeshuamo said:
To add to the "email them" comment, the faculty member who runs the REU at my school said that it's generally a good idea to phrase the email along the lines of:

"You are my first choice for an REU. Please tell me when I can hear about your decision so that I can make plans for any offers I get from other REUs. Ideally, I would love to accept yours."

In your own, more courteous, words, of course.

That's great advice! Thank you so much.
 
  • #50
Yea, I still have not heard from Vanderbilt. Its making me very nervous.
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
105
Views
23K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Back
Top