Polar Coordinate Tracking problem

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the rotation rate of a tracking dish for a plane flying at a constant height and speed. The correct rotation rate is established as 0.05 rad/s, but participants explore various calculations leading to slightly different results, emphasizing the importance of interpreting the distance correctly. There is confusion regarding the impact of gravity on the tracking rate, with participants questioning if the answer would change if calculated on Mars, where gravity differs. The conversation highlights the significance of unit conversion and proper interpretation of the problem's parameters. Ultimately, the role of gravity in this specific tracking scenario remains unclear.
AirForceOne
Messages
49
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



You're tracking a plane from the ground. The plane is at a constant height h from the ground, at a distance r from you at the illustrated instant, and at an inclination theta. The plane's speed is constant at 1200km/hr. Find the rate at which your tracking dish must rotate if r=3km and theta=30degrees. Does the acceleration of gravity make any contribution to your answer?

CCunj.png


The attempt at a solution

The correct answer is 0.05 rad/s.

But this is what I got:

lZEvz.jpg


Sorry for the gigantic image!

Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Check your units.
 
461.88 rad/hr = 0.1283 rad/s

Thanks for pointing that out. Still wrong though :/
 
You resolved i into er and eθ incorrectly. (Try it with θ=90 degrees, for example.) Also, the r in your expression for V isn't equal to 3 km.
 
Why isn't it 3km?
 
I guess it depends on how you interpret the phrase "distance from you." But if you use r=3000 m, the answer is 0.056 rad/s, which rounds to 0.06 rad/s. If you use 3000 km as the horizontal distance from you, you get 0.048 rad/s, which rounds to the answer you cited.
 
Thank you very much. I got 0.06.

What is the meaning of the second part of the question ("Does the acceleration of gravity make any contribution")?

Thanks again.
 
Would you get a different answer if, say, you were on Mars, where the acceleration of gravity is different?
 
Back
Top