Problem with acceleration & distance/displacement:

  • Thread starter Thread starter AznBoi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Acceleration
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving a car's deceleration to avoid hitting a deer. The initial calculation of acceleration was incorrect due to a misunderstanding of kinematic equations and unit analysis. Participants emphasized the need to use proper kinematic equations for constant acceleration rather than simple division of distance by velocity. They also highlighted that time is not necessary to solve the problem when using these equations. The conversation concluded with suggestions for additional resources to help understand physics concepts better.
AznBoi
Messages
470
Reaction score
0
I have showed my work and gotten an answer but it differs from the actual answer in the back of the book. Thanks for your help!

A driver in a car traveling at a speed of 60mi/h sees a deer 100m away on the road. Calculate the minimum constant acceleration that is necessary for the car to stop without hitting the deer (assuming that the deer does not move in the meantime).

My answer is DIFFERENT from the actual answer:

First I converted 60mi/h into m/s:

(60mi/h) x (1609m/mi) x (1h/3600s) = 26.82 m/s

Then I divided 26.82 by 100m : 100/26.82 = 3.73m/s^2

So it's -3.73m/s^2 because it is slowing down??

Did I do the problem wrong? It seems so short so I think I did.

The acutal answer was -3.6m/s^2 What happened??
 
Physics news on Phys.org
AznBoi said:
Then I divided 26.82 by 100m : 100/26.82 = 3.73m/s^2
This step isn't correct, you can check what your doing by using dimensional analysis - check your units;

\frac{velocity}{distance} = \frac{m.s^{-1}}{m} = s^{-1} \neq m.s^{-2}

You need to use kinematic equations to solve this question. Excellent thread presentation though :smile:
 
Take care of your units, you don't get acceleration by dividing a distance with a velocity!
Instead, proceed as follows with x for position, v for velocity and a for acceleration:
\frac{dv}{dt}=a\to\frac{dv}{dt}v=av\to\frac{d}{dt}(\frac{1}{2}v^{2})=\frac{d}{dt}(ax)
where I've used the fact that "a" is constant.
Thus, integrating between initial time and the time when x=100 and v=0, you get:
-\frac{1}{2}(26.82)^{2}=a*100
 
Oh, so is there a proper kinematic equation for every problem??
I don't know which one to use, am I suppose to use the average acceleration one?

a= (delta)v/(delta)t Cause I'm trying to find the average acceleration right? V would be 26.82m/s , but what is the time?? They don't give it.

Btw, we don't have textbooks or anything so I have no book source.

What book would you guys recommend me buying to learn Physics B from the start?

I'm a sophomore and I'm in precal.. so I don't know how to use calculus to solve them and I don't understand many things in PHysics!
 
There is only ONE kinematic equation, with varying additional info given for any particular problem.

In your case, that additional info is first and foremost that the acceleration is CONSTANT.
Read my previous post.

In particular, you'll see that under the assumption of const. acc., you don't NEED the time in order to solve your problem!
 
Last edited:
Last edited by a moderator:
ok I don't really understand any of the equations that you guy put down but I will look at the sources you gave me. Thanks to you both! =]

Physics is very hard.. I mean not only do you need to use algebra but you need to use your head aswell! a lot too. =[ My brain isn't quite expanding.
 
AznBoi said:
ok I don't really understand any of the equations that you guy put down but I will look at the sources you gave me. Thanks to you both! =]

Physics is very hard.. I mean not only do you need to use algebra but you need to use your head aswell! a lot too. =[ My brain isn't quite expanding.
No problem, if you have any question or need any further help don't hesitate to come back :smile: Stick at the physics though :wink:
 
\frac{dv}{dt}=a\to\frac{dv}{dt}v=av\to\frac{d}{dt} (\frac{1}{2}v^{2})=\frac{d}{dt}(ax)

I don't get what d- derivative is. I've read about it and it confuses me. Also what are the arrows and how did you get v-velocity to be placed in there.

so how did dv/dt= a -> dv/dt x v?? confusing.. =P
 
  • #10
This page may explain the calculus more clearly;
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/acons.html#c2

I understand that this stuff may be a bit overwhelming for a pre calc, I would simply recommend learning the formulae without knowing how to derive them before you reach calc.
 
  • #11
ok, I'll see if I can figure it out. Thanks again! :smile:
 
  • #12
\frac{d}{dt}(ax) = \frac{da}{dt}x + a\frac{dx}{dt} = av, since \frac{dx}{dt}=v and a is constant (so \frac{da}{dt}=0).
 
Back
Top