Are you sure you read the question right and put in the right numbers (and in the right places)?
Acceleration of gravity is actually closer to -4.9 m/s^2. And who's the batter, Joe Ascue?
The pitch is 5.875 meters high (about 19 feet high). It might be more likely that 5.875 m was the maximum height and that the question is asking how long the ball stayed in the air (that way you could look at the horizontal component of velocity and see how far the ball went). Note: To solve, you'll still move the h over to the right side of equation, so you can set the entire equation to zero, but then the height will be negative.
Edit: After thinking about it, I'll bet the wall the batter is trying to hit the ball over is 5.875 m high. Your final height is 5.875 m. If you set the equation to zero, it still means the batter's initial height was 5.875 meters below his target, so it should still be (-5.875) in your equation.
And, for those curious, Joe Ascue of the Indians played a key role in the Red Sox winning the 1967 pennant. Late in a 1-run game, the Red Sox tried to intentionally walk him with a man on third and one out, but Ascue outsmarted them. He grounded into a game ending double play.