Proof that a certain semigroup is also a group

  • Thread starter Thread starter dndod1
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Group Proof
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on proving that a finite multiplicative semigroup S, which satisfies specific cancellation laws, is also a group. Participants explore the implications of the cancellation laws to establish that the function λa is one-to-one and onto, leading to the existence of an identity element ea. The identity element is verified through various properties, including associativity and the behavior of elements under multiplication with ea. Additionally, the existence of right inverses for all elements in S is demonstrated, culminating in the conclusion that S meets all group axioms. Ultimately, the discussion aims to confirm that (S, *) qualifies as a group.
dndod1
Messages
9
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Let S be a finite multiplicative semigroup in which these 2 cancellation laws hold. For all a,x,y \in S, a*x=a*y implies x=y and for all a,x,y, \in S x*a=y*a implies that x=y.
Show that (S, *) is a group.

For given a \in S, let \lambda a: S \rightarrow S, s \rightarrow a*s (This should just be a single arrow, can't get it to work!)
a) Show that \lambda a is 1-1 using the cancellation laws. Deduce that it is also onto. Thus show that there is an element ea=a

b) Show that ea * ea= ea by using a*ea= a twice, associativity and then right cancellation.

c) Show that ea acts as an identity, using these solutions for any b\inS.
ea*b =y
ea * (ea *b) = ea
(ea*ea) * b = ea *y
b=y

and
b*ea=y
(b*ea)*ea= y*ea
b* (ea*ea) =y*ea
b=y

d) Now show that any b\inS has a right inverse using the onto property of the function \lambda a. This element, call it br ^-1, itself has a right inverse using the same logic. Call it c. By examining the product of b*br ^-1*c in two ways, show that b=c.

e) Hence obtain that the right inverse br ^-1 is an inverse of b.

f) Conclude logically that (S, *) is a group.


Homework Equations


The Group axioms.
G1 Associativity
G2 Identity element e*g=g*e= g
G3 inverse for each element g^-1*g=e


The Attempt at a Solution


I haven't really got any idea how to start. I only did this before I got stuck:

Outlined the group axioms as above and stated that:
As (S, *) is defined as a semigroup, * is associative, therefore G1 has been satisfied.

a) did not know where to begin as did not know how to go about showing 1-1 and onto.


b) Show (ea*ea) =ea) given a*ea) =a
I don't know whether to work with just the LHS or the whole thing and do the same operation to both sides. I have tried the latter.
a *ea*ea = a*ea
(a*ea)*ea) =a*ea
a* ea=a
a=a ??


I am very, very lost! Please help if you can.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Ok, how to show the map in a) is 1-1:

Suppose there are two elements s and r such that a*s=a*r. If you can show that s=r then you've proven it's 1-1. You should be able to see how to use the cancellation law to prove that s=r
 
Thanks very much for getting me started. I have shown that the function is 1-1 and that it is onto. I still do not know how to tackle the last part of question a), as I am confused by the lambda notation.

Thus show that there is an element ea for each a, such that lambda a(ea)=a.

My undersatnding is that the function lambda takes ea and it will map to a. Is that equivalent to saying that a maps a... which would mean that e is the identity element for a?

Even if that's correct, I am unsure of how to tackle it!
Many thanks again.
 
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...
Back
Top