Really Hard Circuit Question - With LINK

In summary, the conversation involves a person seeking help with a difficult physics question on circuits and providing a picture of the circuit. The questions involve finding the current through different resistors and the power dissipated in specific resistors. There is also a discussion about plotting resistance on a graph. The conversation ends with someone explaining a step-by-step process for finding the current through R4 using potential divider equations.
  • #1
Really Hard Circuit Question- With LINK

Hello there!

I am doing a really tough physics question on circuits . I am attaching the picture of the circuit so you can actually see what is going on :smile:

These are the questions:

a) What is the current through R1?

This one was easy I just found the total resistance of the circuit and used the equation V= IR to get a current of 2.4 A which is the answer/

b) What is the current through R4?

I have no clue how to do this one, no matter what I do I get an answer either to high to to low. The answer should be 0.8 A.

c) What is the power dissipated in R2?

I have a feeling that I can't get this one because I can't get the one before it. The answer should be 5.1W.

d) What is the total power dissipated in the circuit?

I could do this one. It's just p = iv (12.0V)(2.4A) = 29W

Oh and one more really stupid thing. When you are drawing a graph and it says to plot resistance as a function of the cross-sectional area the resistance should go on the x-axis right? :redface:


  • number 36hgfs.jpg
    number 36hgfs.jpg
    12.2 KB · Views: 580
Last edited:
Physics news on
  • #2
There we go this one has the link
  • #3
Oh and just in case you find it hard to read R1 = 3.0 ohms, R2= 2.0 ohms, R3= 1.0 ohms, R4 = 4.0 ohms, R5 = 2.0 ohms
  • #4
please someone help me...I'm desperate!
  • #5
Sorry guy; we're still waiting to see the picture. Can you describe the circuit?
  • #6
a) good.

b) You know that the voltage across the R2,3,4,5 network is the same across the R2-R3 branch, and also the R4-R5 branch. so... if you know the total current going into this network and the resistance of the network R2,3,4,5 you can find the voltage across it. Then you can find the current going through R4-R5.

c) you now know the voltage across the R2-R3 branch from above, therefore you know the current. Take the R2 resistance ...

d) good.
  • #7
I put the picture on as an attachment, it shows up on my computer. I can't really describe the circuit very well without getting everything mixed up. Maybe I'll try attaching it again or something.
  • #8
Thanks for the help Delta, but I still don't really get what to do. When I went back to the question I redid it and got the answers but I know it's not the right way to do it.
For B)

I went Current total is 2.4 A
I total = 2Ir4 + Ir4
2.4 A = 3 Ir4
0.80 A = Ir4
There for the current moving through R4 is 0.80 A.


Ir2 = 2XIr4 there for the current moving through R2 is 1.6 A
V = IR 1.6A x 2.0 ohms = 3.2 V
P= IV 1.6A x 3.2 V = 5.1 W

Therefore the power moving through R2 is 5.1W
  • #9
Hi Scorpa,

for part b, this is the procedure to calculate the current across r 4

you must calculate the pd at the junction of the R (3, 2 and 4) and the positive potential.

you can see that resistors 2,3,4, and 5 is equivalent to 2 ohms by calculating the resistors in parallel.
It follows immediately that the 2 ohm and the r1 forms a potential divider,and the pd across the 2 ohm is : 2/5 * 12v

the pd across the r4 is (another potential divider) 4/6 * 4.8 v

which gives you 3.2 v

then the current through r4 is 3.2v / 4 ohm = 0.8 A
  • #10
Ok so what I did was totally Thanks for the help I'm going to go try it your way now. I did get that the resistance in total across was 2 ohms, but I never tried using a potential divider equation.
  • #11
Could you explain what you have done in more detail? I thought that I understood it but I guess I don't.
  • #12

if we suppose that the r2 and r4 do not exist, then we simply have the 1ohm , 2ohm, and 3 ohm in series totaling 6ohms.

and if you were to find the pd across (r2+r3) you would have 1+2/6 * 12volt = 6 volt
(Using the potential divider , you calculate r2+r3/r1+r2+r3 * 12volts)

But recall that this circuit has r2 and r4 (2ohm and 4ohm) in series across the r2 and r3(also in series).
so you calculated the combined parallel resistance of r2 to r5 to be 2 ohm, which you would expect to be lower the 3ohm.(r2+r3)

now calculate the pd across the same points as above but this time its 2/5 * 12volts = 4.8volt

And finally, we calculate r4/r4+r5 * 4.8volt (using the potential divider) which gives the pd across r4, from which we calculate the current through r4 using V/R=I to give 0.8 Amps

Related to Really Hard Circuit Question - With LINK

1. What is a "Really Hard Circuit Question"?

A "Really Hard Circuit Question" is a type of problem or challenge that requires advanced knowledge and skills in the field of circuitry and electronics. It often involves complex circuits and components, and may require critical thinking and problem-solving skills to solve.

2. How do I approach a "Really Hard Circuit Question"?

To approach a "Really Hard Circuit Question", it is important to first understand the basic principles of circuitry and electronics. Then, carefully analyze the problem and identify the key components and connections involved. It may also be helpful to break down the problem into smaller, more manageable parts and work through each step systematically.

3. What are some common mistakes made when attempting a "Really Hard Circuit Question"?

Some common mistakes made when attempting a "Really Hard Circuit Question" include not understanding the basic concepts and principles, not carefully analyzing the problem, and not following a systematic approach. It is also important to double check calculations and connections to avoid errors.

4. How can I improve my skills in solving "Really Hard Circuit Questions"?

To improve your skills in solving "Really Hard Circuit Questions", it is important to practice regularly and challenge yourself with different types of problems. You can also seek help and guidance from experienced professionals or join a study group to discuss and solve problems together.

5. How does solving "Really Hard Circuit Questions" contribute to the field of science?

Solving "Really Hard Circuit Questions" not only helps to advance the field of circuitry and electronics, but it also contributes to the overall progress of science. It allows for the development of new technologies and innovations, which can have a significant impact on various industries and improve our daily lives.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help