Requesting a letter of recommendation from a Research Advisor

In summary: Any sane scientific supervisor should not link success of failure of project to capabilities of beginner student researcher. Stress your experience and learned skill, and leave the setbacks or progress of project you participated as irrelevant.
  • #1
undefined314
18
20
I'm applying to physics graduate programs this fall. I volunteered with an experimentalist in my hometown (at a small undergraduate-only physics program) over this past summer (I'm going to keep it intentionally vague for privacy reasons, but let me know if you really think the response depends on omitted details). The project experienced a number of setbacks, and my advisor was very understanding about them and confirmed that I could ask them for a letter of recommendation in the future. However, I am uncertain if I should ask them for a letter.

Something that's frequently mentioned is that if you did research under someone, but fail to include a letter of rec from them, people might assume that the project went poorly, unless you've had several advisors (too many to reasonably expect to ask at once).

However, I'm a little bit confused by what is generally meant by "poorly"?

Before I started working, a key piece of equipment was damaged and had to be replaced. On the one hand, from my assessment, there was a significant loss to their research progress during that summer (started with a fully-operational apparatus assembled by previous undergraduates, ended with one that still needs to be reconfigured substantially). On the other hand, I made contributions in computational work, helped with work on restoring the experimental setup (testing the replacement component, re-inserting it into the rest of the setup, etc.), and kept detailed records in my lab notebook. Overall, I think it was good experience for me to learn about the models for an unfamiliar subfield and pick up some experimental techniques.

Is this type of experience unusual (that was my first time working with an experimentalist)? Have you asked for letters of recommendation even if your projects had numerous unprecedented setbacks that were beyond your control?

I might just go ahead and ask them if they'd be willing to write me a strong letter of rec. This feels a bit too direct, but it's been suggested to me many times as general advice. Thanks for any suggestions.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
undefined314 said:
I'm applying to physics graduate programs this fall. I volunteered with an experimentalist in my hometown (at a small undergraduate-only physics program) over this past summer
...
Something that's frequently mentioned is that if you did research under someone, but fail to include a letter of rec from them, people might assume that the project went poorly
...
Overall, I think it was good experience for me to learn about the models for an unfamiliar subfield and pick up some experimental techniques.
...
Is this type of experience unusual (that was my first time working with an experimentalist)? Have you asked for letters of recommendation even if your projects had numerous unprecedented setbacks that were beyond your control?
..
I might just go ahead and ask them if they'd be willing to write me a strong letter of rec. This feels a bit too direct, but it's been suggested to me many times as general advice. Thanks for any suggestions.
1) I think it is not usual to have a formal recommendation letter issued to undergraduate students. My first recommendation letter was at PhD graduation only, and i also went in experimental field (electrical engineering).
2) Any sane scientific supervisor should not link success of failure of project to capabilities of beginner student researcher. Stress your experience and learned skill, and leave the setbacks or progress of project you participated as irrelevant.

As my personal experience, during postdoc time i have one case when the semiconductor foundry my lab collaborated with went bankrupt, ruining the project. It did not adversely affected my career at all - i got the best recommendations and position in aerospace agency immediately after project termination.
 
  • Like
Likes undefined314
  • #3
That's how research goes.

A research mentor shouldn't fault you in a letter of reference for things that were beyond your control.

So long as you were diligent in the work that you did and put in a solid effort, the reference should be fine.
 
  • #4
Ask for the letter. My recommendation letters for undergrads, as well as those from all the other professors I know are based on honest effort and ability rather than research outcomes.
 
  • Like
Likes DEvens
  • #5
trurle said:
1) I think it is not usual to have a formal recommendation letter issued to undergraduate students. My first recommendation letter was at PhD graduation only, and i also went in experimental field (electrical engineering).

Maybe this depends on the locale or program? Maybe I have a different idea of what a formal letter is? I'm thinking a letter the prof sends directly to the school or hiring company or scholarship agency. I got a bunch of those in undergrad. Two jobs, scholarships, then entry to grad school.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes trurle and undefined314

1. How do I request a letter of recommendation from my Research Advisor?

To request a letter of recommendation from your Research Advisor, it is best to approach them in person or via email. Be sure to explain why you are asking for the letter and provide them with any necessary information, such as the deadline and the specific program or position you are applying for.

2. How much notice should I give my Research Advisor when requesting a letter of recommendation?

It is best to give your Research Advisor at least 2-3 weeks notice before the letter is due. This will give them enough time to write a thoughtful and detailed letter on your behalf.

3. What information should I provide my Research Advisor when requesting a letter of recommendation?

When requesting a letter of recommendation from your Research Advisor, be sure to provide them with your resume, a brief summary of your research experience and achievements, and any specific requirements or prompts for the letter.

4. Can I request a letter of recommendation from a Research Advisor I have not worked closely with?

It is not recommended to request a letter of recommendation from a Research Advisor you have not worked closely with. Letters of recommendation should come from individuals who can speak to your skills, abilities, and character with firsthand knowledge and experience.

5. Is it appropriate to ask for a copy of the letter of recommendation from my Research Advisor?

It is not appropriate to ask for a copy of the letter of recommendation from your Research Advisor. This could be seen as a breach of trust and may make your Research Advisor uncomfortable. It is best to trust that they will write a strong and honest letter on your behalf.

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
680
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
6
Views
488
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
936
Replies
1
Views
697
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
1
Views
649
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
6
Views
816
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
4
Views
666
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
25
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
2
Replies
63
Views
4K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
2K
Back
Top