Darth Frodo said:
I apologize both to you and myself for such an error in my judgement.
Is there a rule as to when you are allowed to factorize via taking out what's common? Does the equation have to equal zero?
Let me be a bit pedantic here by saying that an equation does not equal a number. An expression can be equal to a number, but an equation already has an '=' mark in it, so it would be meaningless to say that an equation is equal to zero or any other number.
What you might be alluding to is a theorem that says if the product of two numbers is 0, then one or the other of the numbers, or both, must be 0.
What you had was a(a + 1) = 12, from which you concluded that a = 12 or a = 11. This doesn't work at all. There are lots of ways that two numbers can multiply to 12, such as 1*12, 2*6, 3*4, (1/3)*36, -1*(-12), etc., etc. If you had checked your work, by replacing a with 12, you would have seen that 12(13) ≠ 12. Similarly, if a = 11, you would have seen that 11(12) ≠ 12.
But, by writing the equation as a
2 + 1 - 12 = 0, and then factoring or using the Quadratic Formula, you should come out with the values that are solutions to the equation.