Rotation vs Translation for elbow joint

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
6 replies · 3K views
physics gal
upload_2017-7-19_9-25-1.png


If I were to cut the string and let the board move, I know I would get rotation. But, since the center of mass of the beam is moving as well (in a circle) could I also say that the board is translating once the string is cut?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
.Scott said:
Yes.
Assuming the beam is free to pivot about the hinge at its left end, it would both rotate and translate.
So even though the beam will be tracing a large circle around the hinge (or more likely swinging back and forth) we can call this translation? My reasoning was because the center of mass of the board is moving as it swings. Is that correct?
 
.Scott said:
Yes.
Assuming the beam is free to pivot about the hinge at its left end, it would both rotate and translate.
The Centre of Mass of the board would drop and move to the left so that would be looked upon as translation. To avoid this, you would need to (appropriately) raise the elbow joint and move it to the right. Then you would have only rotation
 
sophiecentaur said:
The Centre of Mass of the board would drop and move to the left so that would be looked upon as translation. To avoid this, you would need to (appropriately) raise the elbow joint and move it to the right. Then you would have only rotation
Even though not all movement vectors of the object are moving in space by the same amount in a given direction, we can still call this translation?
 
physics gal said:
Even though not all movement vectors of the object are moving in space by the same amount in a given direction, we can still call this translation?
Why not? The translation doesn't need to be in a straight line or in a chosen direction. We are talking in terms of translation of the CM.
 
physics gal said:
If I were to cut the string and let the board move, I know I would get rotation. But, since the center of mass of the beam is moving as well (in a circle) could I also say that the board is translating once the string is cut?
Yes, you can decompose the same motion into rotation and translation in different ways.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jbriggs444 and Nidum