Show that the next eigenfunction has a zero between 2 zeros

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Happiness
Messages
686
Reaction score
30

Homework Statement


Printed textbook problem 3.9 on bound-state energy eigenfunctions of a one-dimensional system, asking to prove that between two consecutive zeros of psi_n(x), the eigenfunction psi_(n+1)(x) must have at least one zero.

Printed hint from a textbook: From the Wronskian theorem (p. 110) and the Schrödinger eigenvalue equations satisfied by psi_n and psi_n+1, obtain first the relationship [psi_n' psi_n+1 - psi_n+1' psi_n] from a to b = (2m/h^2)(E_n+1 - E_n) times the integral from a to b of psi_n psi_n+1 dx.


Homework Equations


Wronskian theorem:
Equation (4): the weighted Wronskian W[f, g] from a to b equals the integral from a to b of [F(x) - G(x)] f(x) g(x) dx, printed as a numbered display equation.


The Attempt at a Solution


I've gotten the relationship given by the question but I do not know how to continue.

Since ##\psi_n(a)=\psi_n(b)=0##,
LHS ##=\psi_n'(b)\,\psi_{n+1}(b)-\psi_n'(a)\,\psi_{n+1}(a)##

If LHS ##=0##, RHS ##=0##, then by the First Mean Value Theorem for Integrals, ##\psi_{n+1}(c)=0## for some ##c\in(a,b)##.

But LHS is not necessarily ##0##.

Attached below is the derivation of Wronskian theorem.
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook page explaining the Wronskian determinant of two functions, its zero-at-a-point property, and the Wronskian theorem giving the integral of [F(x) - G(x)]f(x)g(x) over an interval, with the conclusion that the Wronskian of two Schrodinger equation solutions at the same energy is constant.
    Screen Shot 2015-12-10 at 11.59.25 pm.png
    44 KB · Views: 502
Last edited:
As a and b are consecutive zeros of ##\psi_n##, ##\psi_n## won't change sign between a and b.
Assume, without loss of generality, that ##\psi_n## is positive between a and b.
What does that tell you about the signs of ##\psi_n'(a)## and ##\psi_n'(b)##?

Now assume that ##\psi_{n+1}## has no zeros between a and b. It follows that ##\psi_{n+1}## won't change sign between a and b.
Now just check what the signs of the two expressions will be (remember that ##E_{n+1}>E_n##).
 
Last edited: