Solution to z^(2/3) when z=1+i

  • Thread starter Thread starter smutangama
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around finding all solutions to the equation z^(2/3) when z = 1 + i. The polar form of z is correctly identified as √2e^(π/4)i. The participant attempts to compute the argument but encounters a discrepancy with the mark sheet, which suggests an incorrect argument of π/6 + (2πn/3)i. Clarification is sought on whether the problem is to evaluate z^(2/3) or solve z^(3/2) = 1 + i, leading to confusion about the correct approach. The consensus is that the participant's method is accurate, and the mark sheet may contain errors.
smutangama
Messages
12
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Find all solutions to the equation

Homework Equations



z^(2/3)

z=1+i

The Attempt at a Solution



I put it in polar form and got √2e(∏/4)i

Then took the power of that while adding 2∏ni and got

(√2e(∏/4) + 2∏ni)^(2/3)

so the argument here is ∏/6 + (4∏ni)/3

The argument according to the mark sheet is ∏/6 + (2∏n/3)i

where did i go wrong?

thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
look like you are correct...
 
smutangama said:

Homework Statement



Find all solutions to the equation
What equation? The only equation you show is z = 1 + i. In case you're not clear on this, an equation has an equals sign (=) separating two expressions.

Is the problem to evaluate z2/3 when z = 1 + i?
smutangama said:

Homework Equations



z^(2/3)

z=1+i

The Attempt at a Solution



I put it in polar form and got √2e(∏/4)i

Then took the power of that while adding 2∏ni and got

(√2e(∏/4) + 2∏ni)^(2/3)

so the argument here is ∏/6 + (4∏ni)/3

The argument according to the mark sheet is ∏/6 + (2∏n/3)i

where did i go wrong?

thanks
 
smutangama said:

Homework Statement



Find all solutions to the equation

Homework Equations



z^(2/3)

z=1+i
Either "find z^(2/3) where z= 1+ I" or "solve the equation "z^(3/2)= 1+ I". That's what Mark44 was complaining about.

The Attempt at a Solution



I put it in polar form and got √2e(∏/4)i
Yes, that is the correct polar form.

Then took the power of that while adding 2∏ni and got

(√2e(∏/4) + 2∏ni)^(2/3)

so the argument here is ∏/6 + (4∏ni)/3

The argument according to the mark sheet is ∏/6 + (2∏n/3)i

where did i go wrong?

thanks
You are correct that the "general" form of 1+ ix is \sqrt{2}e^{ix(\pi/4+ 2n\pi)} so that the 2/3 power has argument (2/3)(\pi/4+ 2n\pi)= \pi/6+ 4n\pi/3.

If the problem is as stated, the "mark sheet" is incorrect.
 
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...
Back
Top