Solve Star-Delta Starter Problem: Find Starting Torque

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lunat1c
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Starter
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the starting torque of a small induction motor using a star-delta starter. The user derived a formula for starting torque as a percentage of full load torque, arriving at 11.1% based on their calculations. However, they suspect an error in their method compared to their lecturer's answer of 33.33%, which may stem from a misunderstanding of how to handle the current in the equations. The user is seeking clarification on their approach and whether their calculations are indeed incorrect. The conversation highlights the importance of correctly applying formulas in electrical engineering problems.
Lunat1c
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
Hi, I got a small problem which I'm not sure I'm solving correctly. A small induction motor has a short circuit current equal to 5 times the full-load current. I need to find the starting torque as a percentage of full load torque if the motor is started by a star-delta starter. It is also known that the motor has a full load slip of 4%.

Torque = \frac{3I_{R}^2R_r}{(s*\omega_s)}

T_{start}= \frac{3(\frac{5}{3} I_{FL})^2R_r}{\omega_s}

Note that in the above equation i divided the current by three because in a star-delta starter the current is supposed to be 1/3 the direct online current.

and T_{FL} = \frac{3I_{FL}^2R_r}{0.04\omega_s}

Then dividing (1) by (2) i should get \frac{T_{start}}{T_{FL}}=(25/9)*0.04=0.11.

That is equivalent to 11.1% of the Full load torque. However my lecturer got the answer as 33.33%, which is probably because he did \frac{i^2}{3} instead of (\frac{i}{3})^2. Is my answer incorrect?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Anyone please? I have done some additional reading about the problem but I still can't see where I could have made a mistake. The problem is that in another very similar question I also got the answer wrong by using this "method", if you can call it that.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top