Tension between two accelerating blocks

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the tension in a string connecting two blocks, A and B, under the influence of external forces. Block A, with a mass of 4.0 kg, experiences a force of 12 N, while block B, with a mass of 6.0 kg, is subjected to a force of 24 N. Participants emphasize the need to apply Newton's second law by analyzing the forces acting on each block separately to determine the tension. After several attempts and corrections, the correct approach involves calculating the net force and accounting for the forces acting on block A, leading to a final tension value of 2.4 N. The conversation highlights the importance of clearly identifying forces and applying fundamental physics principles to solve the problem accurately.
Fizic
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
Problem text:

Forces act on block A and block B, which are connected by a massless string. Force \vec{F}A=(12 N)\hat{i} acts on block A, with mass 4.0 kg. Force \vec{F}B=(24 N)\hat{i} acts on block B, with mass 6.0 kg. What is the tension in the string?

The system looks something like this:

[A]-----

Relevant equations:

F=ma

Attempt at solution:

The professor never went over tension in class, so I've been Googling the pants off this problem and combing through the book for a solution, each to no avail. I tried working through it for about 30 minutes and gave up in frustration, after having come up with about 6 different answers.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Show what you've tried.

Hint: Identify the forces acting on each mass and apply Newton's 2nd law.
 
Posting anything I've done wouldn't be of value, since everything I tried was essentially the mathematical equivalent of alchemy.

If by apply Newton's 2nd law, you mean add up all the forces, then I come up with Fnet=36N, M=10kg, and A=3.6m/s^2.
 
Fizic said:
If by apply Newton's 2nd law, you mean add up all the forces, then I come up with Fnet=36N, M=10kg, and A=3.6m/s^2.
That's fine. You took as your 'system' both masses together. But to solve for the tension, now analyze the forces on one of the blocks.
 
Doc Al said:
That's fine. You took as your 'system' both masses together. But to solve for the tension, now analyze the forces on one of the blocks.

So...

T=3.6m/s^2*14.4kg=14.4N

Is it really that simple? I'm going to have to kick myself for that!

Anyways, thanks a lot Doc Al!
 
Last edited:
Fizic said:
So...

T=3.6m/s^2*14.4kg=14.4N
Not sure what you are doing here. (Does that equation even make sense? :wink:)

Do this:
Pick one of the masses.
Identify the forces acting.
Apply Newton's 2nd law: ƩF = ma. (You already found the a!)
 
Doc Al said:
Not sure what you are doing here. (Does that equation even make sense? :wink:)

Do this:
Pick one of the masses.
Identify the forces acting.
Apply Newton's 2nd law: ƩF = ma. (You already found the a!)


Woops. Meant to write T=3.6m/s^2*4kg=14.4N

That should be right, no?
 
Fizic said:
Woops. Meant to write T=3.6m/s^2*4kg=14.4N

That should be right, no?
What you have is m*a for the 4kg mass. That's the right hand side of the equation ƩF = ma. But what about the left hand side?

You need to identify the individual forces acting on that mass (one force will be the tension) and then add them to get an expression for ƩF.
 
Doc Al said:
What you have is m*a for the 4kg mass. That's the right hand side of the equation ƩF = ma. But what about the left hand side?

You need to identify the individual forces acting on that mass (one force will be the tension) and then add them to get an expression for ƩF.

So you're saying I need to take into account the 12 N and subtract it from the 14.4 N I just calculated to get 2.2 N of tension force?

Edit:

Nevermind, that was more alchemy. My give up
 
  • #10
Do this: Name the two forces acting on the 4kg mass and tell me the direction they act.
 
  • #11
Doc Al said:
Do this: Name the two forces acting on the 4kg mass and tell me the direction they act.

What I know for sure is that there is a 12N force in the positive direction, and I'm fairly sure that a 14.4N force is being applied, but in which direction I don't know.

Edit:

Here's another try.

\vec{F}T + \vec{F}A=ma

ma-\vec{F}A=\vec{F}T

4kg*3.6m/s2-12N=\vec{F}T

14.4N-12N=\vec{F}T=2.4N
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #12
Fizic said:
What I know for sure is that there is a 12N force in the positive direction,
Good. That force is given.

and I'm fairly sure that a 14.4N force is being applied, but in which direction I don't know.
Don't be guessing the answer--you will solve for it. Just label the force and its direction. (What's exerting the force?)
 
  • #13
Doc Al said:
Good. That force is given.


Don't be guessing the answer--you will solve for it. Just label the force and its direction. (What's exerting the force?)

\vec{F}i=(2.4N)\hat{i}

Final answer.
 
  • #14
Doc Al said:
Again, I don't want the final answer. I want to see you solve for the final answer. (No guessing allowed!)

Hint: The string exerts a tension force--call it T--on the mass. In what direction does the tension pull on the 4 kg mass?

Then write an expression for ƩF, the sum of the forces on that mass.

Wait a sec... Isn't that what I did in post #11? Maybe you didn't see; I edited it.
 
  • #15
Fizic said:
Here's another try.

\vec{F}T + \vec{F}A=ma

ma-\vec{F}A=\vec{F}T

4kg*3.6m/s2-12N=\vec{F}T

14.4N-12N=\vec{F}T=2.4N
Now you're cooking! :approve:
 
  • #16
Thanks to you. srsly
 
Last edited:
Back
Top