Thermodynamics - engines question

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a thermodynamics problem where the user, Jay, is struggling with part d of a question related to engine temperatures and compression ratios. Jay believes that T4 equals T3 and T2 equals T1 but is unsure how to derive T4 and T2 accurately. The conversation highlights the importance of using the ideal gas law and the relationship between pressures and volumes to express temperatures correctly. Jay is confused about how to apply the compression ratios and seeks guidance on calculating T4 and the work done. Ultimately, the discussion emphasizes the need to clarify the relationships between the variables involved in the problem.
Jaydude
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
I'm stuck on a question, part d below:

ImageUploadedByPhysics Forums1426372078.640984.jpg
ImageUploadedByPhysics Forums1426372110.374401.jpg


My attempt:
ImageUploadedByPhysics Forums1426372492.452289.jpg


I reckon that T4 = T3 and T2 = T1, otherwise I don't know how else you can get T4 and T2...?

Once I got first part of d, I reckon I could do efficiency using part c that I derived.

I don't see where I'm supposed to use compression ratios in this question, if someone can direct me to the right path please!

(If this is supposed to be in advanced physics section, please let me know for next time!)

Kind regards,

Jay
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello Jay. Welcome to PF!

Jaydude said:
I reckon that T4 = T3 and T2 = T1, otherwise I don't know how else you can get T4 and T2...?
You are given that ##P_2V_2^\gamma = P_1V_1^\gamma##. See if you can use that along with the ideal gas law to express T2 in terms of T1, V1 and V2.
 
ImageUploadedByPhysics Forums1426442178.074818.jpg


Sweet! But now I'm not sure how to get t4? And how do I apply that to get work done?

I could use my equation (correct) in part b but I don't know what Cp and Cv are, how do I apply the constant 1.4 there?

(I'm going to assume t2 is correct here...)

Thanks!
 
Try a similar calculation to find T4 in terms of T3.
 
TSny said:
Hello Jay. Welcome to PF!You are given that ##P_2V_2^\gamma = P_1V_1^\gamma##. See if you can use that along with the ideal gas law to express T2 in terms of T1, V1 and V2.
TSny said:
Try a similar calculation to find T4 in terms of T3.

But I don't have V3/V4 compression ratio :(
 
Jaydude said:
But I don't have V3/V4 compression ratio :(
How is V4 related to V1? How is V3 related to V2?
 
ImageUploadedByPhysics Forums1426446649.608185.jpg


I see what you did there, but I get the incorrect answer, T4 should be 1379k

What have I done wrong ?
 
How do you justify taking V4 / V3 to be 16?
 
TSny said:
How is V4 related to V1? How is V3 related to V2?
TSny said:
How do you justify taking V4 / V3 to be 16?

If V4 = V1 and V3 = V2, and we know V1/V2 = 16, then V4/V3 = 16 too...?
 
  • #10
I see my problem.

V2 does not equal V3!

Can't solve this, its getting annoying as I've spent hours ripping my hair out on this!
 
Last edited:
  • #11
Bump. Can Someone point me in the right direction here/helpout with the solution? This is only for my practise and is not part of any H/W or Cwk and all of my friends are struggling with this Q too.

Kind regards,
Jay
 
  • #12
V2 does not equal V3, but you can express V3 in terms of V2 using the ideal gas law.
 
Back
Top