Understanding \DeltaH and \DeltaE in Constant Volume Process

  • Thread starter Thread starter phymatter
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Law Thermo
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the distinction between \DeltaH (enthalpy change) and \DeltaE (internal energy change) in a constant volume process. It highlights the relationship defined by H=E+pV and the equation \Delta_V H=\Delta E+V\Delta p, emphasizing that at constant volume, V\Delta p is not zero. Participants debate the validity of equations related to work and energy, clarifying that work is defined as P\Delta V, not \Delta(PV). The conversation stresses the importance of understanding the general equations versus special cases applicable under specific conditions. Overall, grasping these concepts is crucial for accurate thermodynamic analysis.
phymatter
Messages
131
Reaction score
0
What is the difference between \DeltaH and \DeltaE in a constant volume process ?
 
Science news on Phys.org
By definition it is always true that
<br /> H=E+pV<br />
At constant volume you have
<br /> \Delta_V H=\Delta E+V\Delta p<br />
Here you see the difference in the term.
What exactly did you want to know?
 
but acc to first law Heat supplied = internal energy + work done
i.e.
i.e. \Deltah = \DeltaU + \DeltaW
and \DeltaW = \Delta(pv) and
\Delta(pv) = P\DeltaV + V\DeltaP and
for work done V\Deltap is taken as zero so how come can we say here V\DeltaP is not taken as zero here?
 
jeedoubts said:
i.e. \Deltah = \DeltaU + \DeltaW
and \DeltaW = \Delta(pv)

Hi jeedoubts, welcome to PF. Can you give a reference for these two equations? I doubt very much that they're correct. For example, work is defined as P\Delta V, not \Delta(PV).

I agree with Gerenuk's answer.
 
what does the quantity v\Deltap refers to then?
 
The difference between enthalpy change and energy change in a constant-volume process.
 
physically what does it represent??
 
I don't know of a simpler description (other than the literal "volume multiplied by pressure change"). What are you looking for?
 
jeedoubts said:
\DeltaW = \Delta(pv) and
\Delta(pv) = P\DeltaV + V\DeltaP
Neither equation is correct in general. The correct equations are
<br /> \mathrm{d}W=p\mathrm{d}V<br />
(or with the other sign if you consider the work done on the system) and if you wish
<br /> \mathrm{d}(pV)=p\mathrm{d}V+V\mathrm{d}p<br />
It follows that only for constant volume or constant pressure processes the work can be described by
<br /> W=p\Delta V\qquad\text{(const. p or const. V)}<br />
Is it very important to know what is the general equation and what the special case. These special cases only apply if the conditions are met.

Mapes is correct.
 
Back
Top