Understanding the Difference Between NaF and Sulfate/Carbonate in Water

In summary, when a salt such as NaF is dissolved in water, it will dissociate and form HF, creating a basic condition. However, when ions such as sulfate or carbonate react, they form H2SO4 and H2CO3, creating an acidic solution. This may seem contradictory, but both reactions involve a base absorbing hydrogens. The formation of a basic or acidic solution depends on the strength of the base or acid involved. Additionally, in the case of carbonates, the reaction can lead to a multistage equilibrium and the formation of carbonic acid, which is unstable and can easily decompose. In the case of sulfates, the reaction also takes place, but to a lesser extent due to the strength of
  • #1
MotoPayton
96
0
I know that when a salt such as NaF is dissolved in water will dissociate and form HF creating a basic condition.

So why when you you have an ion such as sulfate or carbonate they react to form H2SO4 and H2CO3 they form a acidic solution.

These ideas seem to conflict? In both reactions you have a base absorbing hydrogens but only only in the first reaction a basic solution is formed.

Does this have something to do with the diprotic acid?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
You are confusing something.

F- + H2O -> HF + OH-

yields a basic solution.

CO32- + H2O -> HCO3- + OH-

yields a basic solution as well.

It can even go further:

CO32- + 2H2O -> H2CO3 + 2OH-

but this is a multistage equilibrium, with carbonic acid easily decomposing to water and carbon dioxide, so it is better to not treat this equation too seriously.

In the case of sulfates reaction

SO42- + H2O -> HSO4- + OH-

also takes place (and can increase the pH), although to much lesser extent, as HSO4- is a relatively strong acid (alternatively SO42- is a weak base).
 
  • #3
Okay, I must have misinterpreted something I read.

thanks for helping me out with all my dumb questions, appreciate it
 

1. What is NaF and what is its role in water?

NaF, or sodium fluoride, is a chemical compound that is commonly used in toothpaste and water fluoridation. In water, NaF can act as a source of fluoride ions, which can help prevent tooth decay and improve dental health.

2. How do sulfates and carbonates differ from each other in water?

Sulfates and carbonates are both chemical compounds that can be found in water. However, they have different properties and effects. Sulfates are minerals that can cause water to have a bitter taste and a laxative effect. Carbonates, on the other hand, can increase the pH of water and make it more alkaline.

3. Can the presence of NaF, sulfates, or carbonates in water affect its taste?

Yes, the presence of these compounds can affect the taste of water. As mentioned, sulfates can give water a bitter taste, while carbonates can make it more alkaline. NaF, on the other hand, does not have a significant effect on taste unless present in very high concentrations.

4. Are there any health risks associated with drinking water that contains NaF, sulfates, or carbonates?

In small amounts, NaF, sulfates, and carbonates are generally safe to consume. However, excessive amounts of these compounds can have negative effects on health. High levels of sulfates can cause gastrointestinal issues, while too much fluoride from NaF can lead to dental fluorosis. Carbonates, when present in large quantities, can also cause disruptions in the body's natural pH balance.

5. How can one determine the levels of NaF, sulfates, and carbonates in their drinking water?

The levels of these compounds in water can be measured through water testing. This can be done through a water testing kit or by sending a water sample to a laboratory for analysis. It is important to regularly test the water to ensure that these compounds are within safe levels for consumption.

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
777
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Chemistry
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Chemistry
2
Replies
39
Views
3K
Back
Top