Water wheel and hydroelectric power question

  • Thread starter Pinon1977
  • Start date
12 replies · 2K views · last reply
Pinon1977
Messages
126
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
What type of water wheel is better: even or odd number of moment arms?
Relevant Equations
Not sure
So I'm trying to determine what the advantage would be using a even or odd number of moment arms respective to a water wheel and the torque that it can produce. Part of me wants to say that the odd number armsvwould be best because you would not have an equal opposing Force from the moment arm being utilized. Please see the sketch. As represented by the center line in the three arm waterwheel, there is nothing opposing the force ( Falling water) that's pushing down on the right side of the machine. However, as you seen the 4 arm water wheel, there is the continuation of the arm which, in my mind's eye, we cancel out some of the downward torquing effect. Maybe I'm way off base here.
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn sketches on grid paper of two water wheels: a 4-arm wheel on the left and a 3-arm wheel on the right, with falling water arrows, rotation arrows and a centre-of-plane line.
    IMG_20230622_185951296_HDR.jpg
    52 KB · Views: 163
I would expect (given the design of the wheel in all other regards) there is an ideal number of blades, not necessarily odd or even.
What makes you think the parity matters? Is this an exercise given to you or just curiosity?
 
haruspex said:
I would expect (given the design of the wheel in all other regards) there is an ideal number of blades, not necessarily odd or even.
What makes you think the parity matters? Is this an exercise given to you or just curiosity?
It is an exercise I have given myself. I am going to build one of these configurations and I'm trying to figure out if there's any logic behind my hypothesis.

It just seems like there would be more have a propensity for the system to become overbalanced on one side or the other with an odd number of moment arms.

Now that I'm thinking about it every windmill that I've ever seen is that three blades on it. That may be for other reasons rather than to work. I'm not sure.
 
phinds said:
Why would either of those be better than a standard water wheel:
View attachment 328282
Good question and good point. I am in search of a new design configuration that would be more efficient than the aforementioned the design.
 
Pinon1977 said:
seems like there would be more have a propensity for the system to become overbalanced on one side or the other with an odd number of moment arms.
So long as the paddles are evenly spaced, it will be perfectly balanced regardless of the number.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters
Pinon1977 said:
every windmill that I've ever seen
Traditional stone windmill with a tapered tower and large latticed sails under a blue sky with white clouds, set on a grassy mound.
and boy, have we got a lot of those. For centuries already :smile:

Seems the French have them too

Stone windmill tower with wooden sails and a pyramid-shaped wooden cap against a blue sky, with the caption 'Le moulin d'Alphonse Daudet - Saison 2023' and 'Entrée 2€' printed on the image.

##\ ##
 
Attachments
  • Traditional stone windmill with a tapered tower and large latticed sails, set on a grassy mound under a blue sky with white clouds.
    1687511709571.png
    23.3 KB · Views: 182
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman and pbuk
I'm not sure windmills are a good argument for 4 blades. A modern windmill has 3. I assume that if 4 were more efficient, they would have 4. The thing to keep in mind is that windmills catch wind in ALL of the blades at the same time. Water wheels do not so they are not fundamentally the same at all.
Photo of a three-bladed white wind turbine on a tall tower against a blue sky with wispy clouds.


EDIT: Ah, I see. The 4-wheel configuration was simply a response to the OP's statement that they all have 3, not a claim that it was a better design.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters and BvU
IIRC, the odd number of blades is to avoid (un)balance problems that can result in a mechanical resonance with an even number of blades.

Probably the historic windmills didn't go fast enough for that problem to occur.

Cheers,
Tom
 
Tom.G said:
IIRC, the odd number of blades is to avoid (un)balance problems that can result in a mechanical resonance with an even number of blades.

Probably the historic windmills didn't go fast enough for that problem to occur.

Cheers,
Tom
Interesting possibility… but that would make a prime number even better, no? E.g. 7 better than 9.
 
haruspex said:
Interesting possibility… but that would make a prime number even better, no? E.g. 7 better than 9.
Especially for cicada powered hamster wheels.
 
  • Haha
  • Love
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters, haruspex and kuruman
Pinon1977 said:
I am in search of a new design configuration that would be more efficient than the aforementioned the design.
Have you seen the efficiency numbers in the Wikipedia article for different kinds of waterwheels? It looks like the most efficient are the "overshot" and "backshot" configurations with lots of slots like the picture @phinds posted:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_wheel

Comparison table of two waterwheel types, overshot and backshot, listing wheel type, water impact, driving surfaces, water volume and head, and efficiency of 80 to 90%, with a small diagram of each wheel.