What are some recommendations for a math and physics topic in high school?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around recommendations for a math and physics topic suitable for a high school assignment. Participants explore various themes that integrate both subjects, with a focus on black holes, relativity, and other physics concepts that can be defended in an academic setting.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • Andreas expresses a need for topic recommendations for a math and physics assignment, indicating a preference for black holes.
  • Some participants suggest exploring black holes through resources by Taylor, Wheeler, and Bertschinger.
  • Others propose simpler topics such as the mathematics of Foucault's pendulum or inertial guidance systems, noting varying levels of complexity.
  • Andreas considers writing about the photon sphere and the differences in orbits around spinning versus stationary black holes.
  • One participant suggests using the Schwarzschild solution and nonrelativistic treatments as potential off-ramps for a high school paper.
  • There are discussions about the feasibility of conducting experiments related to these topics, including using accelerometers to measure apparent weight in different scenarios.
  • Andreas contemplates using water vortices to simulate orbits around black holes and mentions programming skills for simulations.
  • Some participants caution against choosing overly complex topics that may not be suitable for the intended audience.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of opinions on the appropriateness and complexity of various topics. While some suggest advanced topics, others recommend simpler alternatives, indicating a lack of consensus on the best approach.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the importance of selecting a topic that balances interest and feasibility, with some suggesting that certain advanced topics may be too challenging for a high school audience.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for high school students seeking topic ideas for assignments that integrate math and physics, particularly those interested in black holes and relativity.

Andreas S-H
Messages
25
Reaction score
0
Hello everyone, I am preparing to write an assignment in math and physics. This assignment will be a sort of exam, where I have to defend it at a later date, I can choose whatever topic I like, as long as it contains math and physics. I need to find something to be my thesis statement (i think it's called that), however I have no idea about what topic i want to write about. So if anyone have any recommendations i would be happy to hear them :).

Kindly Andreas

PS.
I'm on my last year

(sorry for the grammar, I'm not the best at it)
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF.
What year are you ?
What are your interests ?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Andreas S-H
Baluncore said:
Welcome to PF.
What year are you ?
What are your interests ?
Hello :D. I am on my last year. I love everything related to physics, from the tiny to the big, however if i had to choose, it would be black holes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Andreas S-H
Andreas S-H said:
I am on my last year.
Last year in grade school?
Last year in high school?
Last year in college?
Last year in graduate school?
Last year on earth?
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Mr.Husky, Andreas S-H, Astronuc and 5 others
Vanadium 50 said:
Last year in grade school?
Last year in high school?
Last year in college?
Last year in graduate school?
Last year on earth?
High school :)
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Andreas S-H
caz said:
If that is too much for you, notice that the same website also has a book on special relativity, “Spacetime physics”.

The simplest thing I know on relativity is “Relativity and Common Sense“ by Bondi. For a discussion see
https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/relativity-using-bondi-k-calculus/

You should also checkout the Insights Section for ideas
https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/
So far It's not hard (which is good). I need to figure out an experiment i can do to prove something. So this will be fun. Ill check it out. Thanks a lot

Kindly Andreas
 
  • #10
I had to do a report in ninth grade > 50 years ago. I chose black holes, neutron stars, and quasars (exotic physics, especially for that time).
Another interesting thing is the mathematics behind Foucault's pendulum. The math can be extended to inertial guidance system. Or you could do a topic on inertial guidance, with mention of Einstein's principle of equivalence. Another topic is known as the intermediate axis theorem, or the tennis racket problem or theorem.
Some of these topics are a bit complicated at the HS level.
The nice characteristic of some of these suggestions is you can present the idea, that you do not have to treat really exotic physics to find really interesting physics. I've got lots of ideas along these lines with varying degrees of sophistication.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Andreas S-H
  • #11
mpresic3 said:
I had to do a report in ninth grade > 50 years ago. I chose black holes, neutron stars, and quasars (exotic physics, especially for that time).
Another interesting thing is the mathematics behind Foucault's pendulum. The math can be extended to inertial guidance system. Or you could do a topic on inertial guidance, with mention of Einstein's principle of equivalence. Another topic is known as the intermediate axis theorem, or the tennis racket problem or theorem.
Some of these topics are a bit complicated at the HS level.
The nice characteristic of some of these suggestions is you can present the idea, that you do not have to treat really exotic physics to find really interesting physics. I've got lots of ideas along these lines with varying degrees of sophistication.
These are all amazing, after some reading yesterday I thought about writing about the Photon sphere and the difference in orbits if the black hole is spinning or stationary.
 
  • #12
Interesting idea. If you find it tough sledding, you can always use as an "off-ramp", the (easier) difference between the Schwartzchild solution, and the nonrelativistic treatment, (the Kepler problem). This should be plenty for a high school paper.

It is not clear from an earlier post you have to form a critical experiment. Can you do this for many of these exotic ideas?

One idea my colleague (involving general relativity) used a variation of involves Einstein's of equivalence. He used sophisticated equipment aboard ships in a canal. This involved using the accelerometers in a cell phone (or otherwise) to measure your apparent weight in a moving elevator. I think it could also be done (low tech) with a bathroom scale and a camera for recording. To get really sophisticated you can introduce arduino etc. You may be able to take the idea from here, I do not want to give too much away.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Andreas S-H
  • #13
Why pick something so challenging that it still interests you ?
That will be an impossible challenge for the general audience.
Answering the questions presented may be impossible for you.

Instead, teach them all something they will benefit from knowing. Pick something you understand so well, that when you answer the presented questions, you can teach some more.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Andreas S-H
  • #14
Baluncore said:
Why pick something so challenging that it still interests you ?
That will be an impossible challenge for the general audience.
Answering the questions presented may be impossible for you.

Instead, teach them all something they will benefit from knowing. Pick something you understand so well, that when you answer the presented questions, you can teach some more.
If It was to the general audience I would have written about projectile motion, but since the only people who will read it are university professors (My current teacher was a university teacher, and the sensor) It will be okay to write something advanced (according to my teacher) :)
 
  • #15
mpresic3 said:
Interesting idea. If you find it tough sledding, you can always use as an "off-ramp", the (easier) difference between the Schwartzchild solution, and the nonrelativistic treatment, (the Kepler problem). This should be plenty for a high school paper.

It is not clear from an earlier post you have to form a critical experiment. Can you do this for many of these exotic ideas?

One idea my colleague (involving general relativity) used a variation of involves Einstein's of equivalence. He used sophisticated equipment aboard ships in a canal. This involved using the accelerometers in a cell phone (or otherwise) to measure your apparent weight in a moving elevator. I think it could also be done (low tech) with a bathroom scale and a camera for recording. To get really sophisticated you can introduce arduino etc. You may be able to take the idea from here, I do not want to give too much away.
You have a point about the critical experiment, I thought about using a water vortex with laminar flow for the stationary black hole, and a spinning vortex for the spinning black hole, and then seeing how things orbit it close to the centers. I do know quite a bit of programming so I could also do a lot of simulations. But if It is way to exotic I would love to do something along the lines of your last suggestion.
 

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
1K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
3K