What Are the Dimensions and SI Units of Voltage?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the dimensions and SI units of voltage, exploring the relationship between work, charge, and potential difference. Participants are examining the definitions and representations of voltage in terms of fundamental dimensions and units.

Discussion Character

  • Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants are attempting to clarify the fundamental dimensions of voltage, questioning whether electric charge or current should be considered fundamental. There are discussions about expressing voltage in terms of work and charge, as well as the correct representation of its dimensions.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided guidance on the representation of voltage dimensions and units, while others are exploring different interpretations of fundamental dimensions. The conversation is ongoing, with various perspectives on the definitions and relationships involved.

Contextual Notes

There is a noted lack of consensus on whether electric charge or current should be treated as a fundamental dimension. Additionally, the distinction between physical quantities and their units is being emphasized, with references to the SI base units and their representations.

fran1942
Messages
80
Reaction score
0
Hello, we have been asked:

i) State the dimensions of voltage. The work W done to move an amount of charge Q (coulombs) through a potential difference of V volts is given by W = VQ.
ii) state it's SI units.

Would I be correct to say
i) the dimensions are V=J/C or could I word it V=W/Q ?
ii) the SI units are joules and coulombs ?

Thanks kindly for any help.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
i) What are the fundamental "dimensions"? (They're NOT the same thing as units.)

ii) What combination of joules & coulombs? --- J·C, C/J, J/C, CJ or whatever other combination you can come up with?
 
Thanks for your help. I have revised my answers based on your advice:

Would I now be correct to say:

i) the dimensions of Volts are: mass, distance, time and current
ii) the units are J/C
 
ii) is correct.

i) Fundamental Dimensions are: mass, length, time, electric charge, and temperature, represented by the symbols M, L, T, Q, and Θ .

For example: dimensions of acceleration are: LT‒2.

So, in addition to giving the dimensions of Voltage as: mass, distance, time and electric charge, you need to have an exponent where it's needed.
 
In addition to what Sammy said, maybe it is good to note the difference between physical quantities and their units.

fran1942 said:
i) the dimensions are V=J/C or could I word it V=W/Q ?

Both are correct in this case, but that is more or less coincidental. The point here is that the quantity V (voltage) is measured in units of volt, which is also denoted by V.

It is common to write the units of any quantity Q as [Q].
So if the formula for V is V = W / Q, then you could also write [V] = [W] / [Q] - i.e.: the units of V(oltage) are the units of W(ork) divided by the units of Q (charge).
If you use SI units, then [V] = V, [W] = J and [Q] = C.
 
SammyS said:
i) Fundamental Dimensions are: mass, length, time, electric charge,

Current is a fundamental unit, charge is definite in terms of current and time
 
Yes, current is a fundamental unit, but we're looking at dimensional analysis. There's not universal agreement on whether charge or current should be fundamental. In what I looked up, the majority went with electric charge.
 
The problem is not well defined. Volt is also a SI unit, but not a basic one, just like joule and coulomb. Perhaps the unit of voltage in terms of base units (kg, m, s, A) is the question.

ehild
 
CompuChip said:
In addition to what Sammy said, maybe it is good to note the difference between physical quantities and their units.
Both are correct in this case, but that is more or less coincidental. The point here is that the quantity V (voltage) is measured in units of volt, which is also denoted by V.

It is common to write the units of any quantity Q as [Q].
So if the formula for V is V = W / Q, then you could also write [V] = [W] / [Q] - i.e.: the units of V(oltage) are the units of W(ork) divided by the units of Q (charge).
If you use SI units, then [V] = V, [W] = J and [Q] = C.
the formula for V is V = W / Q
then W = F x L,
then Q = I x T
then Dimension for Force (F) is [M][L][T]-2
dimension for Length (L) is [L]
dimension for current Electric (I) is [ I ]
dimension for Time (T) is [T]
so
V = W / Q = (F x L) / (I x T)
V = ([M][L][T]-2[L]) / ([ I ][T])
= [M][L]2[T]-2[ I ]-1[T]-1
= [M][L]2[T]-3[ I ]-1
dimension for Voltage is [M][L]2[T]-3[ I ]-1
 
Last edited:
  • #10
SammyS said:
ii) is correct.

i) Fundamental Dimensions are: mass, length, time, electric charge, and temperature, represented by the symbols M, L, T, Q, and Θ .

For example: dimensions of acceleration are: LT‒2.

So, in addition to giving the dimensions of Voltage as: mass, distance, time and electric charge, you need to have an exponent where it's needed.


I think electric charge not basic quantity...but Electric Current is basic quantity with dimension of electric current is [ I ]
 
  • #11
fran1942 said:
Hello, we have been asked:

i) State the dimensions of voltage. The work W done to move an amount of charge Q (coulombs) through a potential difference of V volts is given by W = VQ.
ii) state it's SI units.

Would I be correct to say
i) the dimensions are V=J/C or could I word it V=W/Q ?
ii) the SI units are joules and coulombs ?

Thanks kindly for any help.
i) dimension for Voltage is [M][L]2[T]-3[ I ]-1
ii) Joule and coulombs not SI units..because SI units using basic units of mks system
there are 7 basic quantity using SI units
Mass, Length , Time , Electric current, Temperature, Luminous Intensity, The amount of subtance. they are represented by the symbols for dimension [M], [L], [T], [ I ], [Θ], [J], and [N] .
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K