What did I do wrong? (Newton's Second Law)

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the acceleration of a 3.0 kg body acted upon by two horizontal forces: 9.0 N due east and 8.0 N at an angle of 62 degrees north of west. Initial calculations incorrectly assumed both forces acted in the same direction, leading to confusion about the correct application of Newton's second law. The correct approach requires considering the components of the angled force, which introduces a vertical component that affects the overall acceleration. Participants highlight the ambiguity in the problem's phrasing regarding "horizontal forces," questioning why vertical acceleration is relevant. Ultimately, the clarification emphasizes the need to account for all force components in the calculation.
th77
Messages
16
Reaction score
0
Only two horizontal forces act on a 3.0 kg body. One force is 9.0N, acting due east, and the othr is 8N, acting 62 degrees north of west. What is the magnitude of the body's acceleration?
Fnet= ma ...so I took that to mean F1x + F2x = ma
F1x = 9 cos 0 = 9
f2x = 8 cos 62 = 3.76
a = (9 + 3.76)/3 = 4.25
The solution says 2.9
 
Physics news on Phys.org
East and west are opposite directions. What does that tell you?
 
I think it tells me that it should be F1 - F2 instead. If yes then

a = (9 - 3.76)/3 = 1.75

It still doesn't come to 2.9
 
Oops, sorry to mislead you a bit.
The MAGNITUDE of the acceleration evidently includes the contribution from the VERTICAL acceleration the body also expriences.
That is, you are to find a=\sqrt{a_{x}^{2}+a_{y}^{2}}
 
You're right because I got the answer using it, but I don't know why. The problem says that only 2 'horizontal' forces act on the object. Why is the vertical involved? I know F2 is making an angle, but then what do they mean by horizontal forces? Shouldn't it just say 'forces'? I have a sample problem in the book that specifies there is one-dimensional motion yet 1 of the forces is making an angle.
 
th77 said:
You're right because I got the answer using it, but I don't know why. The problem says that only 2 'horizontal' forces act on the object. Why is the vertical involved? I know F2 is making an angle, but then what do they mean by horizontal forces? Shouldn't it just say 'forces'? I have a sample problem in the book that specifies there is one-dimensional motion yet 1 of the forces is making an angle.
The phrasing in the book is just dumb, that's all there is to it.
 
thanks for your help
 
Back
Top