What fraction of the air molecules

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the fraction of air molecules that must be expelled from a house when the temperature rises from 17.0° C to 28.0° C. Initial calculations suggested that 3.7% of the air was pushed outside, but confusion arose regarding the correct interpretation of the fraction. Participants debated whether to use the total air at the higher temperature or the lower temperature for the calculation, which could affect the result. Despite confirming the calculation method, one user planned to consult their professor due to persistent issues with the answer being marked incorrect. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding the specific requirements of the problem to arrive at the correct solution.
lalahelp
Messages
74
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


What fraction of the air molecules in a house must be pushed outside while the furnace raises the inside temperature from 17.0° C to 28.0° C? The pressure does not change since the house is not 100% airtight.

Homework Equations


v2/v1=17+273/28+273
=.963


Why is my answer wrong
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You've calculated the fraction that's left inside rather than the fraction that was pushed outside.
 
is it .037?
 
lalahelp said:
is it .037?

Is that a guess or do you have a reason to back up that number?
 
its supposed to says 3.7 percent... I subtracted the 96.3 from 100
 
lalahelp said:
its supposed to says 3.7 percent... I subtracted the 96.3 from 100

Then that's okay. Looks good.
 
I put the answer but for some reason its still saying its incorrect?
 
lalahelp said:
I put the answer but for some reason its still saying its incorrect?

Is there a particular answer format that the question requires? Is it finicky about significant digits?
 
No and No... I am not sure why its doing this.
 
  • #10
lalahelp said:
No and No... I am not sure why its doing this.

:confused: I don't know what else to suggest. I can't think of any other reasonable interpretation of 'fraction of the air molecules' that would lead to a different result.
 
  • #11
yeh, Thank you for your help, I am going to email my proffessor about the question
 
  • #12
Another Homework Helper* has suggested that it is perhaps possible that the question is looking for (n28C-n17C)/n28C ("what fraction of the gas was pushed out") instead of (n28C-n17C)/n17C ("what fraction of the gas will be pushed out"). It would make a small but noticeable difference in the result.


* Thanks D H!
 
  • #13
Yes! that was correct Thank you D H!
 
Back
Top