What is the Constant of Proportionality in Newton's Second Law of Motion?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the constant of proportionality in Newton's Second Law of Motion, specifically how the relationship between force and momentum leads to the equation F=dp/dt. It is established that the units of force are defined such that this constant is 1, simplifying the relationship between force, mass, and acceleration. The Newton is defined as the force required to accelerate a 1 kg mass at 1 m/s², reinforcing that the proportionality constant is one. The conversation also highlights that this definition makes the Newton a relatively small unit of force, as everyday forces are typically much larger. Understanding this proportionality is crucial for applying Newton's laws in practical scenarios.
andyrk
Messages
658
Reaction score
5
"The rate of change of linear momentum of a body with time is directly proportional to the net force acting on it."

=>F\proptodp/dt​
Then how do we suddenly come to:
F=dp/dt?​
We took the proportionality constant as 1 but why?
How to determine that the constant of proportionality is 1?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Linear momentum is defined as p=mv

Assuming there is no change in mass and differentiating,
you get F=dp/dt
 
Expanding on WannabeNewton's post the Newton is defined such that the constant of proportionality is one. Imagine proving by experiment that a is proportional to F/M where the unit of F is yet to be defined. We can write:

a=kF/M

If now we define one Newton as being the resultant force that gives a mass of 1kg an acceleration of 1 metre per second squared then k becomes one.
I could come up with an alternative definition and suggest that the unit of force should be the turnip where one turnip is the resultant force that gives 2.7kg an acceleration 4.6 m/second squared. K would now be an awkward number and I don't think people will use my definition.
 
Dadface said:
Expanding on WannabeNewton's post the Newton is defined such that the constant of proportionality is one. Imagine proving by experiment that a is proportional to F/M where the unit of F is yet to be defined. We can write:

a=kF/M

If now we define one Newton as being the resultant force that gives a mass of 1kg an acceleration of 1 metre per second squared then k becomes one.
I could come up with an alternative definition and suggest that the unit of force should be the turnip where one turnip is the resultant force that gives 2.7kg an acceleration 4.6 m/second squared. K would now be an awkward number and I don't think people will use my definition.

Defining the unit so that the constant of proportionality is 1 also explains why the Newton is such a whoosey amount, meaning that most forces encountered have a large value - like my weight is approx 1000N. A Newton is more like the weight of small chocolate bars.
 
Masquerade178 said:
Linear momentum is defined as p=mv

Assuming there is no change in mass and differentiating,
you get F=dp/dt
Not equal, proportional.
What about the proportionality constant then?
 
Edit: Apologies for the previous post. I read your answers after I submitted mine.
 
Back
Top