Why Are My Calculations for Electrical Resistance and Current Incorrect?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on the inaccuracies in calculating electrical resistance and current using a copper wire and an immersion heater. The user initially attempted to equate the resistance of copper and tungsten wires but made errors in calculating the area and diameter, leading to incorrect results. For the immersion heater, the calculations for current and resistance were also flawed, with discrepancies noted in the derived values. Participants emphasized the importance of correctly applying formulas and checking calculations multiple times for accuracy. Overall, the user is encouraged to revisit their calculations and clarify their understanding of the underlying principles.
jrd007
Messages
159
Reaction score
0
I did all the word but my answers are not matching my books?

1) Can a 2.5 mm-diameter copper wire have the same resistence as a tungsten wire of the same length? Give numerical detials. Answer, yes, 4.6 mm

Here is what I did:
( p = resistivity )

R = p(L/A) so I set R(Cu) = R(tug) and since L is the same it cancels out.

Area = 1/2pie2^2 ---> Cu area = (.5)(3.14)(1.25mm) ---> A = .393 mm

So p(A) = p(A) ---> (1.68 x 10^-8)(.393 mm) = (5.6 x 10^-8)(A)
A = .1179 mm

therefore diameter would be... .1179 mm = 2(pie)r^2
r = .2729 mm which mean diameter = .546 mm... so what did I do incorrect?

2) A small immersion heater can be used in a car to heat a cup of water. If the heater can heat 120 mL of water from 25C to 95 C in 8.0 minutes, (a) How much current does it draw from the car's 12 V battery, (b) What is the resistence? Assume the manufacturer's clain of 60% effciency. Answers: 10 A, 1.2 Olhms

What I did...

Used specific heat equation ---> Q = mcT where I changed 120 mL of water into .120 kg ---> Q = (.120 kg)(4185 J/kg C)(95C-25C)
Q = 35154 J

Then I used the equation PE = 1/2Q(where Q is the charger)V
35151 J = (.5)(Q)(12 V)
Q = 5859 C

Finally I used I(current) = Q/T(time) ---> 5859C/480s
I = 12 A

And for Resistence I used V/I = R ---> 12 V/12 A = 1 Olhm

I am off my two units for some odd reason in my current and off by .2 in my resistence. Did I make a mistake?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Last edited by a moderator:
After sorting through your work, I see several things wrong. What is the area of a circle? Where did you get the number for the area of the copper? Re examine your work you have make some very basic errors.

It is essential that you make a habit of working with symbols until you have isolated the parameter you need a number for. In this case you have.

R = \frac {\rho L} A

I will use a T subscript for Tungsten and a C subscript for copper.

R_T = R_C

so

\frac {\rho_T L_T} {A_T} = {\frac {\rho_C L_C} {A_C}

further you are given that
L_T = L_C

so now we have:
\frac {\rho_T } {A_T} = \frac {\rho_C } {A_C}

A_T = \frac {\rho_C } { \rho_T A_C }

Now can you complete the problem in this same manner until you have isolated the radius of the tungsten?

I have found that it is often necessary to repeat calculations multiple times. Do it until you can get the same answer several times in a row.
 
Last edited:
That does stil not work. Area of copper will be 4.91 mm^2. If you then use.

A_T = \frac {\rho_C } { \rho_T A_C }

You get Area of T = .0611

and then if we use the equation of a circle for this area we get d = .27 mm.
 
Now I see. You actually manipulated the equation wrong. The Area of T is equal to AcPt/Pc. That gives the correct answer. Thanks for a good try though.

Does number two look okay?
 
Thread 'Collision of a bullet on a rod-string system: query'
In this question, I have a question. I am NOT trying to solve it, but it is just a conceptual question. Consider the point on the rod, which connects the string and the rod. My question: just before and after the collision, is ANGULAR momentum CONSERVED about this point? Lets call the point which connects the string and rod as P. Why am I asking this? : it is clear from the scenario that the point of concern, which connects the string and the rod, moves in a circular path due to the string...
Back
Top