Why Can't We Detect Hydrogen with IR Sensors in Explosion-Proof Areas?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Aya ElElbshihy
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hydrogen Sensor
AI Thread Summary
Hydrogen (H2) cannot be detected using infrared (IR) sensors because it is transparent in the IR spectrum, lacking a dipole moment that would allow for absorption of infrared radiation. In explosive environments, such as the petroleum sector, alternative detection methods are necessary. Catalytic and electrochemical sensors are effective for hydrogen detection, as they rely on reactions with ambient oxygen to indicate the presence of gas. These sensors often require additional circuitry for self-testing and maintenance due to their safety-critical nature. Honeywell offers various gas sensors specifically designed for hydrogen detection in industrial applications.
Aya ElElbshihy
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Hi all
My mainly question is about why we won't be able to detect Hydrogen as Ex. gas using IR technology sensors?
Also, I'd like to know if H2 would be detected using IR senosor?
I need to know what is the equivalent technology for this purpose too?
Thanks
Ay ElEbshihy
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
I don't really understand all you are saying (what is an "Ex. gas"?), but I can tell you that H2 is transparent in the infra-red.
 
  • Informative
Likes Aya ElElbshihy
To be more specific, when a homonuclear diatomic molecule like H2 vibrates, there is no change in dipole moment, therefore nothing for an oscillating electric field (EM radiation) to couple with to cause absorption. So H2 doesn't absorb infrared radiation. (The same is true of O2 and N2, which is why we don't have a runaway greenhouse effect.)
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes Astronuc and Aya ElElbshihy
DrClaude said:
I don't really understand all you are saying (what is an "Ex. gas"?), but I can tell you that H2 is transparent in the infra-red.
1st thank you for your reply
I mean in an Explosion proof area like petroleum sector companies
You explained that H2 is transparent in the IR so what is the another solution to avoid this point
Thank you
 
mjc123 said:
To be more specific, when a homonuclear diatomic molecule like H2 vibrates, there is no change in dipole moment, therefore nothing for an oscillating electric field (EM radiation) to couple with to cause absorption. So H2 doesn't absorb infrared radiation. (The same is true of O2 and N2, which is why we don't have a runaway greenhouse effect.)
1st thank you for your reply
What is the another solution to avoid this point
Thank you
 
It shouldn't be hard for you to google "hydrogen gas detector"
 
  • Like
Likes Nik_2213
IIRC, there's two temperature sensitive resistances, one coated with a catalyst, run side-by-side in a bridge arrangement. Catalysed, any hydrogen reacts with ambient oxygen, alters its leg's temperature and resistance, unbalances the bridge...

Similar tech checks for 'general flammable vapour', such as methane etc and toxic gas such as Carbon monoxide. But, because such are less responsive to ambient catalytic oxidation, they may need to be warmed. Think how car exhaust catalysers don't work well until hot enough...

The extra circuitry and protocols for self-testing and maintenance of such safety-critical equipment is well beyond my amateur reading.

FWIW, some of our hydrogen-flame GCs had an internal leak sensor, which had to be replaced at service intervals as air pollution progressively poisoned the active surface.

Um, also Google 'Faraday Lamp'...
 
Aya ElElbshihy said:
1st thank you for your reply
I mean in an Explosion proof area like petroleum sector companies
You explained that H2 is transparent in the IR so what is the another solution to avoid this point
Thank you
Honeywell makes a variety of gas sensors, including sensors for hydrogen. Catalytic and electrochemical sensors are used to detect hydrogen, and they require oxygen.
See Chapter 10, starting on page 36, and see Table on page 43 in
https://www.honeywellanalytics.com/~/media/honeywell-analytics/documents/english/11296_gas-book_v5_0413_lr_en.pdf?la=en-gb
 

Similar threads

Back
Top