News Will the US reintroduce the draft?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Art
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Draft
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the potential reintroduction of the military draft in the United States, prompted by rising military casualties and recruitment shortfalls in the Army. Senator Biden emphasized that the U.S. may face a difficult decision regarding the draft due to ongoing recruitment challenges, with the Army missing its targets significantly. The conversation reflects concerns about the implications of a draft, with some participants arguing that an all-volunteer force is preferable and expressing skepticism about the likelihood of reinstating conscription. Many believe that a major global conflict, such as a war with China, would be necessary to justify a draft, while others dismiss the idea as political fear-mongering. The discussion also touches on military training standards for new recruits and the potential consequences of deploying inexperienced soldiers. Overall, there is a consensus that the draft is unlikely to be reinstated without a significant escalation in military conflict.
  • #201
russ_watters said:
I find these words ironic coming from someone who doesn't even live in a democracy, much less the American one...

It really is true that you cannot fully understand what something is like (real freedom, for example) until you experience it. Once you experience it, then maybe you will understand why people would put on that uniform and defend it.

you are funny as always.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #202
stoned said:
you are funny as always.

Do you care to offer any real contribution to this thread?
 
  • #203
The Smoking Man said:
So how long have you spent living in China, Russ, that you think you are in a position to judge what goes on here and then condemn me for 'not knowing what goes on in a democracy'?

I was there in Hong Kong twice for a week at a time, does that count? :-p

Townsend (is not serious...)
 
  • #204
Townsend said:
Do you care to offer any real contribution to this thread?
Maybe he was offering an opinion.

Maybe he should get his own URL so you can quote him.
:wink:
 
  • #205
The Smoking Man said:
Maybe he was offering an opinion.

Maybe he should get his own URL so you can quote him.
:wink:

Plagiarism...that is MINE...so you had better at least give me the credit...

And his opinion is welcome, however when it is a pointless opinion that's not related to the topic it does not offer anything to this thread.

And one last thing...stop trying so hard to sound slick, it's a farce and is not becoming of your style at all. Not trying to be a prick, just offering up some constructive criticism.

Regards,
 
  • #206
Townsend said:
And his opinion is welcome, however when it is a pointless opinion that's not related to the topic it does not offer anything to this thread.

And one last thing...stop trying so hard to sound slick, it's a farce and is not becoming of your style at all. Not trying to be a prick, just offering up some constructive criticism.

Good

Remember where you wrote this when I throw this too in your face.
 
  • #207
The Smoking Man said:
Good

Remember where you wrote this when I throw this too in your face.

Ooh...you're gettin me all excited with anticipation...I can't wait to see what you come up with.

Townsend (gets a shiver up his spine)

p.s. Don't worry, I won't forget it... :approve: and where is my credit?
 
Last edited:
  • #208
Only for a total war scenario, which is unlikely. But if a draft was reinstated, I would gather up all my friends from high school and we'd fight together. :smile:
 
  • #209
Brady said:
Only for a total war scenario, which is unlikely. But if a draft was reinstated, I would gather up all my friends from high school and we'd fight together. :smile:
Yes but would you fight in the war?
:biggrin:
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
15
Views
4K
Replies
17
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
20
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
5K
Replies
33
Views
6K
Back
Top