What Is the Correct General Solution for the Equation sin(x)sin(y) = 1?

[zorro]

Homework Statement

The general solution of sinx.siny=1 is

1.x=n(pi)+(pi/2)(-1)^n+1 y=m(pi)+(pi/2)(-1)^m+1
2.x=(4n+1)(pi/2) y=(4m+1)(pi/2)
3.x=(4n-1)(pi/2) y=(4m-1)(pi/2)

where n,m belong to I

Homework Equations

Answer- 2 and 3

The Attempt at a Solution

This is possible only if sinx=siny=1 or sinx=siny= -1

Substituting arbitrary values of n,m in 1st choice...we get correct answer
but 1st choice is not included in correct answers
WHY?

 

[Mentallic]

Frankly, I don't see the point of having y=f(n) since y=x.
The first doesn't work because you can choose n and m such that sin(x)=-sin(y) so sin(x)sin(y)=-1

The general solutions are x= \pi/2 +2\pi n such that sin(x)=1, and y=-\pi /2 +2\pi n such that sin(y)=-1. These are equivalent to your second and third equation.

z=\pi/2+\pi n gives sin(z)=\pm1