Why is the Sun Expanding Beyond Earth in Seconds?

In summary, the Sun is currently halfway through its H-He fusion cycle and will eventually reach its Fe state before undergoing fission reactions. It is believed that during the red giant phase, the Sun will expand and possibly envelop the inner planets, though this may take a significant amount of time. It is not possible for the Sun to expand to this size in a matter of seconds due to the limitations of matter traveling at the speed of light. The expansion will also result in the Sun cooling and becoming redshifted, giving it the name "red giant". This process will also result in the formation of heavier elements, with fewer atoms due to fusion and depletion. The expansion of the Sun is a gradual process and does not occur in a matter
  • #1
oilfan04
2
0
Alright. Now, I understand that the Sun is 1/2 way through its complete H-He fusion cycle, and I realize that after this fusion cycle, it will pass through all the elements until Fe, (i don't know whether it passes through each element in 7 seconds, or it takes 7 seconds for each element). My question is, if the atoms are getting larger as you go farther down the table, and the Sun would theoretically expand (possibly) to Jupiter's position in that short time, and considering that matter cannot travel faster than the speed of light, how does this work?

I know, I shouldn't think in classical physics terms, but I can't seem to find an answer. The reason being, is that it takes 8 minutes for light to reach Earth from the Sun, however, the Sun would be expanding far beyond Earth in a matter of seconds. Why?

P.S. my Physics teacher had told me how far the Sun would expand to, so I'm using his information.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Can you explain to me why you think that the sun would expand this far in a matter of seconds? I always thought that the expansion to red giant stage would take place more gradually. Also, I remember reading that a star like the sun would expand enough to envelop the inner planets, but not the outer ones, contrary to what your teacher said. Anyone?
 
  • #3
Well, I understand that the Sun will undergo fusion reactions until its Fe state, then fission occurs.

Again, time and sizes have been from my teacher's mouth, not mine. But the question is, if matter cannot exceed the speed of light, and it takes 8 minutes for light to reach the earth, then why is it taking only a matter of seconds for the Sun to pass through all the fusion reactions and expand to envelop the inner planets? Thinking classically, it's not possible. However, on another level of physics it is, and I'm asking why.

Sorry if I'm going around in circles on this one.
 
  • #4
I not one to contradict your teacher, but what he's saying just isn't making sense to me. Nothing with mass, can travel at or faster than the speed of light. Gravity travels at light speed, so should anything happen to the sun, on Earth we would feel it 8 mins later, and so on and so forth.
Our sun will most problably go through as cepheid said, a red giant phase. In a red giant phase, as a star has used up it's outer H-He, it they begins to fuel itself with H from a relatively small shell around it's core. Because fusion is occurring so close to the core (creating heavier elements, like you said stoping at iron) the star's outer levels begins to expand. To expand it uses up energy (beating the sun's gravity), so the star is cooled and redshifted.
The star becomes larger and larger, cooler and cooler, giving it the name red giant. It will most probably envelop the inner planets (mars might get excluded), though due the gravitational concequences of the red giant phase, the inner planets might be lost in space. This procces does not happen in seconds or minutes, it takes quite an amount of time, but I don't know exactly.

1 extra thing, remember though the atoms are getting heavier, there are less and less of them, for 1: because they are being fused, and 2: the star is running out of them.
 

1. Why is the Sun expanding beyond Earth in seconds?

The Sun is not actually expanding beyond Earth in seconds. This is a common misconception. The Sun is a star and its size remains relatively constant. The apparent increase in size may be due to atmospheric conditions or optical illusions.

2. Is the expansion of the Sun a sign of an impending apocalypse?

No, the Sun's expansion is not a sign of an impending apocalypse. The Sun is a dynamic object that goes through cycles of activity and is expected to continue to do so for billions of years. There is no evidence to suggest that the Sun's expansion is a cause for concern.

3. How does the Sun's expansion affect Earth?

The Sun's expansion has little to no direct effect on Earth. Its size and activity are closely monitored by scientists, but its distance from Earth and the protection of our atmosphere prevent any significant impact on our planet.

4. Will the Sun eventually engulf Earth?

No, the Sun will not engulf Earth. While the Sun will continue to expand in the future, it is estimated that Earth will no longer be habitable long before the Sun reaches its largest size. The Sun's expansion is a natural part of its life cycle and will not have a direct impact on Earth's existence.

5. Can we stop the Sun from expanding?

No, we cannot stop the Sun from expanding. This is a natural process that is beyond our control. However, scientists are constantly monitoring the Sun's activity and are researching ways to better predict and prepare for any potential impacts on Earth's environment and technology.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
23
Views
3K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
38
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
962
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top