What is Space: Definition and 1000 Discussions

Space is the boundless three-dimensional extent in which objects and events have relative position and direction. In classical physics, physical space is often conceived in three linear dimensions, although modern physicists usually consider it, with time, to be part of a boundless four-dimensional continuum known as spacetime. The concept of space is considered to be of fundamental importance to an understanding of the physical universe. However, disagreement continues between philosophers over whether it is itself an entity, a relationship between entities, or part of a conceptual framework.
Debates concerning the nature, essence and the mode of existence of space date back to antiquity; namely, to treatises like the Timaeus of Plato, or Socrates in his reflections on what the Greeks called khôra (i.e. "space"), or in the Physics of Aristotle (Book IV, Delta) in the definition of topos (i.e. place), or in the later "geometrical conception of place" as "space qua extension" in the Discourse on Place (Qawl fi al-Makan) of the 11th-century Arab polymath Alhazen. Many of these classical philosophical questions were discussed in the Renaissance and then reformulated in the 17th century, particularly during the early development of classical mechanics. In Isaac Newton's view, space was absolute—in the sense that it existed permanently and independently of whether there was any matter in the space. Other natural philosophers, notably Gottfried Leibniz, thought instead that space was in fact a collection of relations between objects, given by their distance and direction from one another. In the 18th century, the philosopher and theologian George Berkeley attempted to refute the "visibility of spatial depth" in his Essay Towards a New Theory of Vision. Later, the metaphysician Immanuel Kant said that the concepts of space and time are not empirical ones derived from experiences of the outside world—they are elements of an already given systematic framework that humans possess and use to structure all experiences. Kant referred to the experience of "space" in his Critique of Pure Reason as being a subjective "pure a priori form of intuition".
In the 19th and 20th centuries mathematicians began to examine geometries that are non-Euclidean, in which space is conceived as curved, rather than flat. According to Albert Einstein's theory of general relativity, space around gravitational fields deviates from Euclidean space. Experimental tests of general relativity have confirmed that non-Euclidean geometries provide a better model for the shape of space.

View More On Wikipedia.org
  1. P

    Stargazing Can distance in space be measured by human systems?

    I'm past middle age, and it seems I should have fewer questions about life and the universe than ever. I have more now. For some reason this past year or so I've been absolutely consumed with trying to grasp the immensity of the universe and distances. For whatever reason, I'm having more...
  2. K

    Ideas for novel I'm writing I would love some insight on a concept

    Summary:: Ideas for a novel I want to begin writing. Brainstorming ideas and need help with a certain concept. Any help is appreciated! Hello to you all, this is my first post, and I Google searched this astrophysics forum because I thought it might be a good place to begin asking for advice...
  3. L

    A Probability and entropy in an exponentially increasing sample space

    Hi, I'm new to PF and not really sure which forum may be the most appropriate to find people with an interest in probability and entropy. But the title of this forum looks promising. If you share an interest in this topic would be delighted to hear from you.
  4. Wrichik Basu

    How should I distribute space among different partitions in Ubuntu?

    I have had enough with my Windows PC. I have decided to create a dual boot PC with Ubuntu 20.04 LTS. I am doing a dual-boot system because I need Windows for: Amazon prime video app MS office Here is a view of the partitions of the HDD: I have a lot of programs to install: MATLAB Android...
  5. M

    Engineering Converting a series connected transfer function to the state space model

    Hi, I have a question about a homework problem: I am not sure why I do not seem to get the same answers when using different methods. Question: Given transfer functions G(s) = \frac{s - 1}{s + 4} and C(s) = \frac{1}{s - 1} , find the state space models for those systems. Then find the...
  6. T

    Time dilatation between straight and curved lines in Minkowsi space

    Summary:: Special relativity - 2 astronauts syncronize their clocks and moves in different paths at different velocities, which clocks is left behind? and why? Hi everyone, i have the following problem and I'm not understanding if my strategy to solve it is correct: Two astronauts synchronize...
  7. J

    I Constrains on experimental space and parameters

    There is this argument that any new forces of nature or any new interactions would have very small gap of space left in the experimental space or parameter. The argument being that for every force, there is a particle and a field, and virtual particles. And the virtual particles can affect...
  8. C

    I Gravity: Compounded Space (Time) Signal?

    Disclaimer - I am not an expert by any means so this might be as much about confirming my understanding as an inquiry from the general public... as such, it might be fairly conversational as I attempt to clearly communicate my thoughts and understanding. Please excuse this. If gravity is the...
  9. sahilmm15

    B Length is the measure of intervals in space?

    What does 'intervals' mean here?
  10. M

    LaTeX How to decrease spacing before single space environment in LaTeX?

    Hi, Question: How can I remove the extra spacing above the single-space equation environment. I have wrapped the equations in a single-space environment as the document has to be double spaced (and I wanted to save as much space as possible) From reading online, I have the following code at...
  11. Eumeme

    B Gravitational Wave System and Locations

    My hypothesis: A sequence with the gravitational waves detected, sent by modulating radio waves, could be received and used by other intelligent beings to find the corresponding sequence within their records and then compare it to calculate our spacetime position in relation to theirs. As...
  12. R

    How Does Space Travel Affect Natural Aging?

    Changes in the body that come from space travel resemble growing older, providing opportunities to perform aging studies on astronauts. https://www.nmn.com/news/how-does-space-travel-affect-natural-aging Any validity to this?
  13. S

    Vector space of linear maps

    Solution 1. Based on my analysis, elements of ##V## is a map from the set of numbers ##\{1, 2, ..., n\}## to some say, real number (assuming ##F = \mathbb{R}##), so that an example element of ##F## is ##x(1)##. An example element of the vector space ##F^n## is ##(x_1, x_2, ..., x_n)##. From...
  14. J

    B Are subspaces of Hilbert space real?

    When orthogonal states of a quantum system is projected into subspaces A and B are A and B real spaces?
  15. Decimal

    I Completeness relations in a tensor product Hilbert space

    Hello, Throughout my undergrad I have gotten maybe too comfortable with using Dirac notation without much second thought, and I am feeling that now in grad school I am seeing some holes in my knowledge. The specific context where I am encountering this issue currently is in scattering theory...
  16. E

    Here is a 3D model I made of the Mir space station

    This is a 3D model I made of the Mir space station.
  17. dlgoff

    How to Make a Vertical Stabilizer for a Model Space Shuttle Discovery

    I hope it's appropriate to post a picture of a battery operated model of the Space Shuttle Discovery which flew in the 1960's ; lights and sounds. I came across it at the antique mall. It's missing it's vertical stabilizer, but I can make that,
  18. Martian2020

    B General Relativity and the curvature of space: more space or less than flat?

    General relativity. Curvature of spacetime: ok. time dilation: ok. What about space? Curvature is intrinsic and given by complex equations. But could we definitely say is there more space between 2 points along curved space through the star than would be through flat space (no star there) or...
  19. kyphysics

    I Does Humidity "Disperse" and "Even Out" in Enclosed Space?

    I have a dehumidifier (just one) that is placed indoors in the house in a "central" location (maybe not perfectly center, but close). Obviously, the local humidity around the machine will get sucked out of the air and turn to water. But, would the humidity in a different part of the house be...
  20. LCSphysicist

    Is this a curved or flat space?

    I would appreciate if someone check my work: I tried to simplify the answer a lot: I imagined that, if we have this ds between two points different than the distance that should be if the space was flat, so it would be enough to generalize and say that space is not flat. So, using this...
  21. archaic

    Finding a matrix from a given null space

    I have solved the exercise, so I'm not giving the vectors explicitly. I just want to know if there is a quicker way than mine. We know that ##A## must have ##4## columns and ##4## lines, and we also know that its nullity is ##2##, thus its rank is ##2##. I took the simplest matrix that can have...
  22. S

    B Question about things moving through outer space

    Apparently, if I have this down correctly, even the vacuum of outer space has a density, and thus matter in it. With that, I have a few questions: I think I know what happens when something moves in a vacuum at high speeds, namely around and at light speed. Now, for much slower speeds, I must...
  23. M

    B Nervous about James Webb Space Telescope?

    The Hubble Telescope helped us to see how enormous the universe really is. We now know from data built up from that that the universe likely has 2 trillion galaxies in it. Now when James Webb gets out their and starts taking better pictures; I’m afraid the count of galaxies will jump to 10 or...
  24. LCSphysicist

    Not sure about this statement in vector space and matrix

    Be ##T_{1}, T_{2}## upper and lower matrix, respectivelly. Show that we haven't matrix ##M(NxN)## such that ##M(NxN) = T_{1}\bigoplus T_{2}## I am not sure if i get what the statement is talking about, can't we call ##T_{1},T_{2} = 0##? Where 0 is the matrix (NxN) with zeros on all its entries...
  25. S

    Converting State Vectors to Keplerian Orbital Elements for Binary Objects

    Homework Statement:: I'm working on a personal project to convert objects from a simulation using state vectors for position and velocity to Keplerian orbital elements (semimajor axis, eccentricity, argument of periapsis, etc.). However, the equations I am using do not calculate the...
  26. F

    Vector space of functions from finite set to real numbers

    Summary:: Problem interpreting a vector space of functions f such that f: S={1} -> R Hello, Another question related to Jim Hefferon' Linear Algebra free book. Before explaining what I don't understand, here is the problem : I have trouble understanding how the dimension of resulting space...
  27. LCSphysicist

    Prove a theorem about a vector space and convex sets

    Summary:: Be the set X of vectors {x1,...,xn} belong to the vector space E. If this set X is convex, prove that all the convex combination of X yet belong to X. Where convex combination are the expression t1*x1 + t2*x2 + ... + tn*xn where t1,...,tn >= 0 and t1 + ... + tn = 1 I tried to suppose...
  28. steve1763

    I Parallel transport on flat space

    When parallel transporting a vector along a straight line on flat space, does the connection (when calculating the covariant derivative) always equal zero? Do things change at all when using an arbitrary connection, rather than Christoffel symbols?
  29. E

    I Entanglement and Regions of Space in Vacuum

    Sean Carroll (in a video) claims that regions of empty space (vacuum) that are near each other must be highly entangled. He appears to argue that if they were not, there would be "a lot of energy contained there" which - my conclusion - would not be consistent with these regions being low energy...
  30. T

    MHB Proving Zp is a Vector Space for Prime p

    How can I prove that Zp is a vector space if and only if p is prime
  31. F

    I Proving linear independence of two functions in a vector space

    Hello, I am doing a vector space exercise involving functions using the free linear algebra book from Jim Hefferon (available for free at http://joshua.smcvt.edu/linearalgebra/book.pdf) and I have trouble with the author's solution for problem II.1.24 (a) of page 117, which goes like this ...
  32. D

    A Name for a subset of real space being nowhere a manifold with boundary

    I was wondering if anyone knew of a name for such a set, namely a subset S \subseteq \mathbb{R}^n which at every point x \in S there exists no open subset U of \mathbb{R}^n containing x such that S \cap U is homeomorphic to either \mathbb{R}^m or the half-space \mathbb{H}^m = \{(y_1,...,y_m)...
  33. Py3_3

    I Determining Relative Position of Space Object to Earth

    Hello, i'm doing a project where the goal is to get the relative position of a space object to the earth, roughly. Basically, i want to say that this object is currently e.g. above New York. The data for any given space object that i have is (It's sourced from an NASA API). The specific...
  34. cestlavie

    How much energy would enter your pupils from an explosion in space?

    The answer is 1.1 J, but I don't know how to get there. The only equation I can think of that might be related to this is Intensity, which I've added above. I could find area, using .0004m as the diameter, and energy using 2.0 E 46 J, but I get stuck on energy.
  35. BillTre

    The International Space Station as a Human Abode

    The NY Times, on the 20th anniversary (on Halloween) of the ISS being continuously occupies, published an article (with lots of pictures and a really cool time line) showing what the inside of the ISS is like. Duct tape on the ISS (didn't see any WD-40): Galley: Science stuff:
  36. L

    A Integrability along a Hilbert space?

    Suppose we have an infinite dimensional Hilbert-like space but that is incomplete, such as if a subspace isomorphic to ##\mathbb{R}## had countably many discontinuities and we extended it to an isomorphism of ##\mathbb{R}^{\infty}##. Is there a measure of integrating along any closed subset of...
  37. mfb

    Space inhabited non-stop for 20 years

    People under 20 have never lived at a time without at least two people in space. Exactly 20 years ago, on Halloween 2000, Soyuz TM-31 launched the first long-term crew towards the ISS to start Expedition 1. They docked 2 November. Since then the ISS has been inhabited continuously. This was by...
  38. T

    I Earth's Rotation & Orbit: Effects on Space Objects?

    Hi. I don't know what prefix this question belongs in so I just chose advanced at random. What's the physical effect called when the Earth orbits around the sun at extremely fast speeds and also rotates around itself every 24 hours at the same time? Does that force cause anything in space...
  39. Spinnor

    Rocket Launch as Seen from the Space Station

    Almost looks like an animation but it is from NASA.
  40. justinpaul

    Calculating Velocity Vector of Object in 2D Space

    The question I am trying to solve is what is the velocity vector (direction and magnitude) of an object in 2 d space. We know the distance measured to the car from two different angles. We know the radial velocity of the car on both measurements. The radial velocity is the component of the...
  41. J

    I Energy in the Hamiltonian formalism from phase space evolution

    The hamiltonian ´for a free falling body is $$H = \dfrac{p^2}{2m} + mgy$$ and since we are using cartesian coordinates that do not depend on time and the potential only depends on the position, we know that ##H=E##. For this hamiltonian, using the Hamilton's equations and initial conditions...
  42. Ozen

    Help With Shrinking a Circuit/Making it Fit Into a Tight Space

    Attached is the schematic for the circuit. It uses a TPS61042DRBT LED driver along with a PSoC 4000 8pin microcontroller to drive a 10mA LED with push button controls for brightness. The problem is some components, like the inductor and sense resistor is way too large (over 6mm long!). This is...
  43. phyzguy

    Efficiency of a heat engine in space

    I have a question about building efficient heat engines in outer space. In theory you could have a hot reservoir heated by the sun that was several hundred degrees C, and a cold reservoir that was very cold - maybe 50K - 100K or even colder. Thus, theoretically at least, a heat engine could be...
  44. thaiqi

    I Dynamical System & Hilbert Space: Analyzing the Relationship

    Is there any relation between dynamical system and Hilbert space(functional analysis)?
  45. N

    Temperature of a Solar panel in space

    Consider two 1 square meter marble slabs each of mass 1 kg floating in space facing the sun such that light from the sun incident perpendicularly on the flat faces. At equilibrium, power received from the sun 'PS' equals the power being lost in the form of radiation 'PR'. PS = PR (at...
  46. T

    I Launch to Space: Exploring the Possibility of a Tube Launch System

    Build a tube to space. Use our atmosphere to push a ship up the tube.
  47. LCSphysicist

    Killing’s equation in a linear space

    Be f a orthogonal transformation and g being in the canonical form. $$[f^{-1}]^{t}[g][f^{-1}] = [g']$$ So this equation of isometries implies that the diagonal of g is +- 1, but, apparently, if it is minus one it can't be a group, and i don't know why. To make the things clear, if det = +1, in...
  48. Buzz Bloom

    I Q: Volume of the largest ellipsoid in space which contains no stars?

    The answer to the primary question in the summary is the first step in seeking an answer to a more complicated question I plan to post in a separate thread later. This more complicated question is a consequence of the thread...
  49. S

    I What "space" is used in defining cosmological distributions?

    I assume 3-D cartesian space is not an adequate description for things at the cosmological scale. So what definition of "space" is used when people talk about things like the distribution of hydrogen atoms "in the universe"?
Back
Top