Calculating Corrosion Allowable Factor for SA516-70 Material?

  • Thread starter Thread starter doan
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Corrosion
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on determining the corrosion allowable factor for SA516-70 material used in pressure vessel design. Participants emphasize that the corrosion factor is influenced by various factors, including the specific application, material properties, and expected corrosion types. It is noted that uniform corrosion assumptions may not apply to scenarios involving pitting or crevice corrosion. Several corrosion allowance values for different fluids are provided, but caution is advised regarding the unpredictability of corrosion in real situations. Ultimately, adherence to established standards, such as the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, is recommended for safe pressure vessel design.
doan
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Dear all,
I have one question about corrosion factor. How to find it? (may be have 1 table to determine it? )
thanks!
N-Doan
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Corrosion factor of what?

You're asking a very broad, yet vague question.
 
Sorry,
I asked about corrosion allowable factor of material, which using to design pressure vessel.
Thanks!
N-Doan
 
As SteamKing indicated, "I have one question about corrosion factor. How to find it?" is a very broad and vague statement.

It depends on a number of factors that go into design.

I've determined it for a very specific case/application (including a specific material with known range of yield/tensile strength), and it was derived from the maximum allowable wall thinning over the service life, in conjunction with minimum wall thickness and maximum pressure (stress) allowed. The corrosion was assumed to be uniform, so it would not apply for a case where pitting or crevice corrosion might occur.
 
Dear "Astronuc",
I've never see the formula contained time service of pressure tank (Service life). Could you determined for me to understand?
And I had some information. Is it correct? Can I use it to calculate wall thickness of other parts in pressure vessel?

Corrosion allowance for carbon steel pipes (Ca) mm


Superheated steam = 0.3


Saturated steam = 0.8


Steam coils in cargo tanks and liquid fuel tanks = 2.0


Feed water for boilers in open circuit systems = 1.5


Feed water for boilers in closed circuit systems = 0.5


Blow-down systems for boilers = 1.5


Compressed air = 1.0


Hydraulic oil = 0.3


Lubricating oil = 0.3


Fuel oil = 1.0


Thermal oil = 1.0


Fresh water = 0.8

Sea water = 3.0

Cargo systems for oil tankers = 2.0

Cargo systems for ships carrying liquefied gases = 0.3

Thanks,
N-Doan
 
Doan - your original question puts us on difficult ground before we start - corrosion and pressure vessels is a bad combination .

If the situation were absolutely unavoidable I would seek information about out what type and rate of corrosion was commonly found in the particular type of pressure vessel and work from there .

Problem is that extent , depth and rate of corrosion can be very unpredictable in a real situation . If you expect corrosion to be a problem then the only answer is overkill on thickness and a very rigorously applied schedule of inspection .

Far better to use proper pressure vessel materials which are corrosion resistant and proven to be suitable in use intended - there are many to select from .

Don't want to be unhelpful - tell us more about what you are actually doing and perhaps we can come up with better answers .
 
Thanks,
We have designed steam system with SA516-70 material.
and the choose corrosion allowable is very important in this case.
Could you teach to me in this case (Ca value).
N-Doan
 
Back
Top