Can a Time Machine Reverse the Universe Instead of Time?

  • Thread starter Thread starter runicle
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Homework Time
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a textbook question about time travel and whether a time machine could reverse the universe instead of time. Participants express skepticism about the validity of the textbook, suggesting it may contain misleading information about time travel concepts. The conversation touches on the nature of time as a fourth dimension and questions the textbook's credibility. Some users humorously suggest discarding the textbook due to its questionable content. Ultimately, the discussion highlights the confusion and curiosity surrounding the topic of time travel and its implications in physics.
runicle
Messages
75
Reaction score
0
I had a question in my textbook saying "You have a time travel machine and you traveled to the year 1948, explain how the time machine did it?"
---------------------------------------------------------------------
First isn't time constant, a one way street which you can't put in reverse, because there's cars behind you? Second, if that's true wouldn't it be that the time machine didn't reverse time, but reversed the universe not affecting time at all?
---------------------------------------------------------------------
This is an advanced question in the textbook, so could anyone give me some facts or a website so i can research?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Look in the section of the book which is associated with that homework set.

'Usually' the information you need is contained in the chapter preceding the question.

What topics are you currently learning from your textbook?
 
Is this a creative writing course, or science? If the former, just use your imagination. If the latter, I have to wonder what kind of textbook you have. You can't build a time machine, so there's no way to explain how one works.
 
Thanks i got it now. Time is a fourth dimension which i find doesn't relate to space. Could it be possible that everything revolves around time? So basically there's only 3 dimensions?
 
What textbook is this?
 
Its a Canadian textbook in ottawa physics grade 11
 
runicle said:
Its a Canadian textbook in ottawa physics grade 11

Throw it away :bugeye:


:devil:
 
moose said:
Throw it away :bugeye:
:devil:


ditto.

and burn it. What kind of textbook claims to know how time travel would work?
 
  • #10
This is simply shocking
Lodge a formal complaint to your headmaster that a sub-quality textbook is used in your physics course. .
 
  • #11
I'd like to see the textbook... maybe it was like... the rough in the diamond? lol. Maybe a typo... out of context?

If its what we think it is though... better hope they don't say that gravity works because there's lots of apples on earth.
 
  • #12
runicle said:
Its a Canadian textbook in ottawa physics grade 11

Would you please the title and authos of book, and page on which the question occurs.

My wife's sister teaches grade 11 physics in the GTA (Greater Toronto Area, for non-Canadians), and I wonder if she's uses the same text.

Regards,
George
 
  • #13
Well first off it was a trick question and i don't remember, because it was a little while back i had the book.So, that's why the question wasn't worded correctly, because i still remembered some context of the question and i still don't know the answer to the trick question...
 
  • #14
Riiiiggghhhtttt... now you tell us that it was a trick question. And before that, you had to go and scare the **** out of me by suggesting that a Canuk textbook would have something like that in it.
Until now, I didn't realize that either you or George were fellow Canuks. And by the way, George, my cousin used to be the police chief in Brandon. Should I know you because of that?:-p
 
  • #15
Danger said:
And by the way, George, my cousin used to be the police chief in Brandon. Should I know you because of that?:-p

Really?!

I arrived in Brandon about 5 months ago. Before that I lived in Toronto, before that in West Virginia, before that on St. Croix, before that in Quebec before that in Toronto, before that in Windsor, ...

I try to stay one step ahead of the posse!

Regards,
George
 
  • #16
It was quite a while before that, George. His name is Dave McNamee. And I spent from '65 to '78 2 miles north of Ruthven, 5 miles from Leamington, 35 miles SE of Windsor. (A Kingsville High non-graduate.)
 
  • #17
Well, the question got at least one student wondering and investigating, which is more than can be said for most handbooks. Maybe the question was in a chapter that talked about special relativity which will then lead one to think that one should answer the question by explaining why such a machine would not work.
 
  • #18
Well said andrevdh
 
Back
Top