Can someone explain the diffraction of electrons through a single hole?

  • Thread starter Goodver
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Electrons
In summary, the conversation discusses the mechanism of diffraction of electrons through a single hole and how it relates to the Huygens-Fresnel principle. It also touches on the concept of electrons as waves and their behavior in a vacuum. The expert provides a helpful explanation of electron diffraction, clarifying the role of the Schrodinger equation and boundary conditions. They also correct the misconception of electrons as little spheres and explain the interaction of electrons with the walls of the slit. The expert also confirms the application of Huygens-Fresnel principle to all waves and notes that there is currently no explanation for the propagation of waves. They also correct the previous understanding of electron travel and provide a more accurate depiction.
  • #1
Goodver
102
1
Could anyone please explain the mechanism of diffraction of electrons through the single hole. Have a look on the picture attached.

It says if we would shoot only one electron at a time, the pattern would be the same.

Things which are confusing me:

1. If the source of emitted electrons is far from the grating (holes), then the direction of "flying" electrons is perpendicular to the plane of holes. According to De Broglie particles propagate as waves and not as a straight line. Since electrons are not accelerating, they are not emitting any waves by themselves. Thus the electron can be seen as a flying sphere (combined waves in all planes) right?.

Why the electron is changing its direction when passing through the whole? What influence on changing of its direction?

I understand how diffraction works in uniform medium (Huygens–Fresnel principle), but... see 2

2. According to Huygens–Fresnel principle, every point to which a luminous disturbance reaches becomes a source of a spherical wave.

Since the experiment on the picture happens in vacuum, then what is a "point to which a luminous disturbance reaches" in vacuum? Like I understand if its in water or any other uniform medium, but what can be hit in vacuum?
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2013-09-14 at 12.12.25 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2013-09-14 at 12.12.25 PM.png
    73 KB · Views: 484
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Attachment is from "University physics with modern physics, Yound and Freedman, 13 edition"
 
  • #3
You have stumbled upon the basic problem with quantum theory. It works, but it is almost impossible to explain, particularly if you are looking for a classical analogy.

Electrons have wave properties, so they diffract somehow.
 
  • #4
Goodver said:
I understand how diffraction works in uniform medium (Huygens–Fresnel principle)
Then you should have no trouble with electron diffraction. It is conceptually the same.

Goodver said:
Could anyone please explain the mechanism of diffraction of electrons through the single hole.
There is no mechanism. The reason it happens is that the probability amplitude for the electron obeys the Schrodinger Equation, and the boundary conditions for it are altered by the presence of the slit, and this changes the solution.

Goodver said:
1. If the source of emitted electrons is far from the grating (holes), then the direction of "flying" electrons is perpendicular to the plane of holes. According to De Broglie particles propagate as waves and not as a straight line. Since electrons are not accelerating, they are not emitting any waves by themselves. Thus the electron can be seen as a flying sphere (combined waves in all planes) right?.
No, an electron is not to be thought of as a little sphere, in any sense. A beam of electrons traveling in a single direction is represented as a plane wave.

Goodver said:
Why the electron is changing its direction when passing through the whole? What influence on changing of its direction?
It interacts with the walls of the slit, and momentum is transferred from slit to particle.

Goodver said:
2. According to Huygens–Fresnel principle, every point to which a luminous disturbance reaches becomes a source of a spherical wave. Since the experiment on the picture happens in vacuum, then what is a "point to which a luminous disturbance reaches" in vacuum? Like I understand if its in water or any other uniform medium, but what can be hit in vacuum?
Huyghens principle does not require something to be hit. It's a heuristic way to visualize a solution of the wave equation. The wave propagates itself continuously, as if all points on the wavefront were acting as little transmitters, but that does not mean there's a bunch of tiny little physical objects present to do the transmitting.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
Bill_K, that was really helpful, had to reread some facts I thought were clear for me.

If you don't mind, could you please also correct my logic expressed in the following questions as well?

1. Huygens–Fresnel principle applies for all waves, right?
Mechanical when we are dealing with mass and momentums (water for instance)
and
Electromagnetic/quantum when we deal with photons (no mass)

2. There is no explanation why a wave propagates such a way yet? Like why each next point of a wave is a source of lateral wave which propagates in all directions (sphere).

3. Before I thought that electron travels as depicted in pic. a. Is my logic presented on the attached picture correct now?
 

Attachments

  • photo.jpg
    photo.jpg
    57.8 KB · Views: 381

1. What is the diffraction of electrons?

The diffraction of electrons is a phenomenon in which electrons behave like waves and exhibit interference patterns when passing through a narrow slit or around an obstacle. This behavior is similar to the diffraction of light.

2. Why do electrons diffract?

Electrons diffract because they have wave-like properties, such as wavelength and frequency, in addition to their particle-like properties. When electrons encounter a barrier, their wave nature causes them to bend and diffract around it.

3. What is the relationship between the size of the slit and the diffraction pattern of electrons?

The size of the slit is directly proportional to the diffraction pattern of electrons. This means that as the size of the slit decreases, the diffraction pattern becomes wider and more spread out.

4. How is the diffraction of electrons used in scientific research?

The diffraction of electrons is used in a technique called electron diffraction, which is used to study the structure of crystals and molecules. This technique allows scientists to determine the arrangement of atoms within a material and their distances from each other.

5. Can electrons diffract in a vacuum?

Yes, electrons can diffract in a vacuum as long as there is a barrier or obstacle present for them to diffract around. However, the diffraction pattern may be different in a vacuum compared to a medium with particles present, due to the absence of interactions with other particles.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
21
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
3
Replies
81
Views
4K
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
4
Views
951
Replies
1
Views
8K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
54
Views
5K
Replies
6
Views
785
Replies
9
Views
1K
Back
Top