Can't get correct sign for a simple force problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mr Davis 97
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Force Sign
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the force of kinetic friction acting on a block subjected to a tension force. The user initially defines the direction of forces, labeling tension as positive and friction as negative, but encounters confusion when their calculation yields a positive value for friction. Responses clarify that the sign of the force indicates direction, and the user mistakenly applies absolute values and cosine functions, which alters the expected sign of the friction force. It is suggested to avoid using absolute values and cosine to maintain the correct directional sign in calculations. The correct approach emphasizes understanding vector direction rather than solely focusing on magnitudes.
Mr Davis 97
Messages
1,461
Reaction score
44

Homework Statement


A tension force of 2.50 N acts horizontally on a 2.00 kg block. The block accelerates at 0.750 m/s2. What is the force of kinetic friction?

Homework Equations


Fnet = ma = F1 + F2 + F3 + . . .

The Attempt at a Solution


I define the reference frame to be, in terms of an x axis, positive to the right and negative to the left. Thus, the force of tension is positive because I define it to be in the right direction, and the force of friction should be negative since it opposes the tension.

##F_{fx}## = force of friction
##F_{tx}## = tension

##F_{netx} = ma = F_{tx} + F_{fx}##
##F_{fx} = ma - F_{tx}##
##\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \|cos(180^{\circ}) = ma - \left \| \vec{F_{t}} \right \|cos(0^{\circ})##
##-\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \| = ma - \left \| \vec{F_{t}} \right \|cos(0^{\circ})##
##\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \| = \left \| \vec{F_{t}} \right \|cos(0^{\circ}) - ma##
##\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \| = (2.50 ~N) - (2.00 ~kg)(0.750 ~m/s^{2})##
##\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \| = (2.50 ~N) - (1.50~N)##
##\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \| = 1~N##

As we can see, I get positive 1 N rather than -1 N. Why is this? What am I doing wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Mr Davis 97 said:
I define the reference frame to be, in terms of an x axis, positive to the right and negative to the left. Thus, the force of tension is positive because I define it to be in the right direction, and the force of friction should be negative since it opposes the tension.
You don't need to say what is "left" and what is "right." For example, I would of set up the directions as: "the positive direction is the direction of tension and the negative direction is the direction opposite of tension." At any rate, this doesn't affect your answer.

Mr Davis 97 said:
##F_{fx} = ma - F_{tx}##
##\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \|cos(180^{\circ}) = ma - \left \| \vec{F_{t}} \right \|cos(0^{\circ})##
I'm not sure why you're doing this... But this step is why it turns out positive instead of negative. All you did in this step was multiply Ff by -1 (without multiplying the other side by -1) which is why your answer came out altered by a factor of -1

Mr Davis 97 said:
##\left \| \vec{F_{f}} \right \| = 1~N##

As we can see, I get positive 1 N rather than -1 N. Why is this? What am I doing wrong?
Anyway, doesn't the ||...|| mean "the magnitude of ... "? The magnitude of -1N is 1N.
 
your absolute value Force is positive ... what direction does it push? (The sign of a vector tells its direction)
... I suggest you NOT use absolute values, and not use cos(180), so you get the F_x component with sign still attached.
 
Thread 'Collision of a bullet on a rod-string system: query'
In this question, I have a question. I am NOT trying to solve it, but it is just a conceptual question. Consider the point on the rod, which connects the string and the rod. My question: just before and after the collision, is ANGULAR momentum CONSERVED about this point? Lets call the point which connects the string and rod as P. Why am I asking this? : it is clear from the scenario that the point of concern, which connects the string and the rod, moves in a circular path due to the string...
Back
Top