Centripetal force throughout a vertical circle

AI Thread Summary
In vertical circular motion, the centripetal force is often misunderstood, particularly regarding its greatest point. While some argue that the centripetal force is highest at the bottom due to maximum velocity, others assert it is greatest at the top, factoring in gravitational effects. The discussion highlights that the problem's ambiguity regarding speed and gravitational influence leads to confusion. Clarification is needed on whether the motion is at constant speed or influenced by gravity, as this affects the interpretation of centripetal force. Ultimately, the centripetal force is derived from the vector sum of tension and gravity, making context crucial for accurate answers.
Matthew_B
Messages
9
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


In what position in vertical circular motion is the centripetal force the greatest?
Top, Bottom, Left, or Right

Homework Equations


Can someone explain how Fc is greatest at the top?

The Attempt at a Solution


I had reasoned that since centripetal acceleration which I will assign to a is equal to v^2/r and as a result of the velocity being greatest at the bottom the centripetal acceleration (a) will also be the greatest at the bottom
Since the formula for centripetal force is Fc= ma and the mass remains constant I said that Fc will be the greatest where the centripetal acceleration (a) will be the greatest which is the bottom.
When I received my test back I was told that the centripetal force is greatest at the top rather than the bottom can someone please explain?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The question is ill posed as it is not stated what velocity the circular motion has. If it is just subject to gravity and a constraining force, the correct answer is at the bottom.

One could also ask where the constraining force is the greatest (with constant speed or with speed given by motion in a gravitational field - in both cases the answer is at the bottom).
 
Orodruin said:
The question is ill posed as it is not stated what velocity the circular motion has. If it is just subject to gravity and a constraining force, the correct answer is at the bottom.

One could also ask where the constraining force is the greatest (with constant speed or with speed given by motion in a gravitational field - in both cases the answer is at the bottom).
The problem from the test had no mention of gravity or the speed at any of the given points, however I assumed that gravity is present and the velocity is changing since the that is the type of problems we have covered in my class. Do you think then that it was indeed a problem with the key? Thank you for responding to my post also.
 
Matthew_B said:
The problem from the test had no mention of gravity or the speed at any of the given points, however I assumed that gravity is present and the velocity is changing since the that is the type of problems we have covered in my class. Do you think then that it was indeed a problem with the key? Thank you for responding to my post also.

I wouldn't worry about it. Whoever set the test probably got their calculations mixed up.
 
My point is, regardless of whatever reasonable assumption you make about the velocity, the centripetal force will be greater at the bottom. The answer provided by your teacher is then simply wrong.
 
Orodruin said:
My point is, regardless of whatever reasonable assumption you make about the velocity, the centripetal force will be greater at the bottom. The answer provided by your teacher is then simply wrong.
Aright thanks for the reply
 
Hang on a moment. I think you are confusing the centripetal force with the tension in the string. The centripetal force is always constant. The tension in the string will vary but not the centripetal force.

The centripetal force Fc is always mv^2/r that's made up of the vector sum of the tension in the string and gravity.
 
Last edited:
CWatters said:
Hang on a moment. I think you are confusing the centripetal force with the tension in the string. The centripetal force is always constant. The tension in the string will vary but not the centripetal force.

The centripetal force Fc is always mv^2/r that's made up of the vector sum of the tension in the string and gravity.
He is not confusing them. You are making the assumption that the motion is with constant speed, which clearly the OP does not.
 
  • #10
Orodruin said:
He is not confusing them. You are making the assumption that the motion is with constant speed, which clearly the OP does not.
You're right I missed that.
 
Back
Top