Confusion with formulas for wavefunctions

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
5 replies · 2K views · last reply
Cocoleia
Messages
293
Reaction score
4

Homework Statement


I am working on this problem:
Text problem: a particle of mass m moves in a two-dimensional box of sides L; (a) write wavefunctions and energies in terms of quantum numbers n1 and n2 in the xy plane; (b) find ground and first excited state energies and whether either is degenerate.


The formula I am given in my notes is:
Handwritten particle-in-a-box wavefunction: psi with subscript n-vector, of r-vector equals (sqrt(2/L))^3 times sin(n1 pi x / L) times sin(n2 pi y / L) times sin(n3 pi z / L).

I found a website which explains this problem, and they give this formula:
Formula for a particle-in-a-box wavefunction: psi(x, y, z) equals the square root of 8 over L1 L2 L3, times sin(n1 pi x / L1), times sin(n2 pi y / L2), times sin(n3 pi z / L3).

But then, their answer is:
Handwritten solution to problem 7a: the boxed wavefunction psi(x,y) = (2/sqrt(L1 L2)) sin(n1 pi x / L1) sin(n2 pi y / L2), then 'since L1 = L2 = L', psi(x,y) = (2/L) sin(n1 pi x / L) sin(n2 pi y / L), with a circled +3.

And I don't see how they went from sqrt(8) to 2 on the numerator. I am confused which formula to use where.
I am confused as to which formula I should use... my notes don't make any difference between L1, L2 and L3, but then it doesn't matter in this case in the end.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You have found a solution for the 3D problem. Yours is the 2D problem, which is slightly different.
 
PeroK said:
You have found a solution for the 3D problem. Yours is the 2D problem, which is slightly different.
The solution I found was supposed to be for the exact same problem I am working on. In this case do I use the formula from my notes ? Or there is a completely different one that I am forgetting ?
 
PeroK said:
You have found a solution for the 3D problem. Yours is the 2D problem, which is slightly different.
Could I use this one:
Handwritten equation: psi sub n equals the square root of 2 over L, multiplied by sin of n pi x over L.

and then add the y-component somehow ?
 
Cocoleia said:
Could I use this one:
and then add the y-component somehow ?

You've found the 1D solution and the 3D solution. I think you are supposed to solve the 2D problem for yourself!
 
Cocoleia said:
Could I use this one:
View attachment 115925
and then add the y-component somehow ?

Yes, your problem in 2- or 3 dimension is separable. That, is the wave function for the 2-dimensional problem can be written as a product of two wave functions, one depending on ##x## and the other on ##y##.