Density change of an object with mass

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on whether the density of an object changes as its speed increases according to the principles of special relativity. It is established that proper mass density varies by a factor of γ (the Lorentz factor), while mass-energy density varies by γ² due to both mass and volume changes. The confusion arises from understanding why these factors differ and how they relate to Lorentz contraction, which only affects dimensions parallel to the direction of motion. Participants seek a qualitative explanation for these differences, emphasizing the need for a physical understanding rather than just mathematical derivation. The conclusion suggests that the answer to the initial question depends on the type of density being referenced.
sudipmaity
Messages
48
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



This is an introductory special theory of relativity short question from university question paper that carried 2marks.
Does the density of an object change as its speed increases? if yes by what factor.


Homework Equations



m=m0/√[1- (v/c)2]
L=L0√[1-(v/c)2]



The Attempt at a Solution


My guess is yes .
If 1/√[1-(v/c)2]=γ lorentz factor
ρ=m/L3=m/volume(V)=(m0/V0) *γ4
ρ/ρ04.
No textbook has exclusively covered this problem except for one.
There it is written for proper mass density
ρ/ρ0=γ and it is γ2 for mass-energy density.
And V=V0/γ.
The author only mentioned the relations.Did not derive them either concisely or in detail.
I am now confused.How come lorentz factor has the same power for both length and volume?
Why and how does proper mass density and mass-energy density have different factor?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If an object has a velocity in the X-direction, are all three spatial dimensions Lorentz contracted?
 
The answer to your question is no.But nobody said here about a velocity in x direction.What if for the most general case the object is traveling in an 3d space.Shouldn't all the components contract?
 
No, all components don't contract, only the component in the direction of motion. It doesn't matter what direction it is, I just used the X-direction to make the question simpler. If it is moving with a uniform velocity, I can always rotate my coordinate system and call the direction of motion the X-direction.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Ok so that clears up the volume factor. Could you please explain the proper mass density and mass energy density factor difference?
 
After thinking on my own question what I feel is in the case PROPER MASS DENSITY variation is only due to contraction in dimension of the body parallel to its direction of motion.Hence V=V0/γ.
m=m0.
So ρ=ρ0γ.
But for MASS-ENERGY DENSITY both the mass and volume change.
Mass increases :m=m0γ
Volume changes as above.
So ρ=ρ0γ2.
Am I right?
Do you guys concur?
If yes then what should be right answer to my first post?
Should it be γ or γ2?
 
Your reasoning is correct. As to the answer to your first question, it depends on which they are asking about. I would think that the word density refers to the proper density, but I'm not really sure.
 
What still makes my mind itch is my inability to explain the answer physically.
My answer was clearly out of mathematical intuition.
Can somebody explain PHYSICALLY why proper mass density varies by a factor γ while mass energy density by γ2?
What could be the best possible QUALITATIVE explanation?
 
Back
Top