Electric field distance problem

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the electric field at a distance z from the center of a uniformly charged spherical surface of radius r, addressing both cases where z is less than and greater than r. Participants emphasize the importance of showing previous work and not expecting immediate assistance without effort. Key points include using the law of cosines to express the distance and integrating the electric field components correctly. Specific suggestions are made regarding the integration process and the need to rewrite formulas for clarity. The conversation highlights the challenges of the calculus involved and encourages a methodical approach to solving the problem.
physicscnewb
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
ok, here is the question, i need it by tomorrow:

find the electric field of a distance z from the center of a spherical surface of radius r, which carries a uniform charge density sigma. treat the case z<r(inside the sphere) as well as z>r(outside of the sphere)> Express your answer in terms of the total charge Q on the sphere. (suggestion: use the law of cosines to write ro in terms of r and theta. be sure to take the positive sq rt) (also keep in mind that in spherical coordinates, unit vectors have nonzero derivatives)

thanks in advance
 
Physics news on Phys.org
1) Do not post the same question in multiple places.

2) Do not expect anyone to treat your problem as an emergency, because you procrastinated on starting it.

3) Do not expect us to do your homework for you. Show what you've done so far, show us where you're stuck, and then we'll help you.

- Warren
 
4) Why do so many emergency questions in these forums come from members with one post?

(no disrespect to the regular members who post their work and ask for hints...)
 
i drew a diagram

i found ro, which is sq rt (z^2 + r^2 - zrcos(theta))

i also have dl = dr r direction + r dtheta theta direction + r sin theta d phi phi direction

da =r62sintheta dthetadphi

dE = sigma/4piE0 da/ro squared

i need someone to help me with the calculus.

thanks in advance
 
anyone willing to help?
 
ok, i did what i can. i don't know what more you want me to show so you could help me. if you are unwilling or unable to help, just say so. I am just asking for a response. is that asking for too much?
 
anyone knows how to integrate that thing?
 
btw, you are not allowed to use gauss's law
 
anyone at all?
 
  • #10
Sorry nobody wanted to help ... or remembered how to do this (?).
1) you forgot the "2" in the law of cosines. you'll NEED it ...
2) Integrating around phi you'll get 2 pi ... and only the E_z will be non-zero.
3) dE_z = dE cos(alpha) ... get a formula for cos(alpha) from law of cosines.
4) Integrating theta from 0 to pi has this nasty denominator (& in alpha)
re-write the entire thing in terms of ro, so the denominator is clean.
Yes, the numerator is messy, but that's at least do-able. not so bad.
5) Integrate ro from z-R to z+R.

Give it a try ... the most important thing with E-fields is the distance
from source point to Field point ; secondary importance is dQ at that distance. Object orientation ... who cares?
Good Luck.
 
Back
Top