I Energy Released in Stellar Nucleosynthesis

AI Thread Summary
The mass defect in nuclear physics indicates the difference between the mass of a nucleus and the sum of its constituent nucleons, directly relating to the binding energy released during nuclear fusion. To calculate the binding energy for the proton-proton chain reaction, the correct values for protons, neutrons, and the nucleus mass must be used, with energy already represented in MeV. A common mistake is multiplying the binding energy by c^2, as MeV is already an energy unit. The accurate energy released during the proton-proton chain is approximately 26.731 MeV, not the initially calculated 28.2958 MeV. Understanding the initial and final states of the reaction is crucial for accurate calculations in stellar nucleosynthesis.
Amrator
Messages
246
Reaction score
83
This is taken from page 226 in Essential Astrophysics by Lang:

"The mass defect, ##ΔM##, for a nucleus containing ##A## nucleons, ##Z## protons, and ##A-Z## neutrons is
$$ΔM = Z m_p + (A - Z) m_n - m_{nuc}$$ where ##A## is the mass number of the nucleus, ##Z## is the atomic number, ##m_p## is the mass of the proton, ##m_n## is the mass of the neutron, and ##m_{nuc}## is the mass of the nucleus.

The binding energy, ##E_B##, used to assemble the nucleus from its constituent nucleons is:
$$E_B = ΔM c^2$$ The binding energy measures how tightly bound a nucleus is."

So mass defect represents both the difference between the mass of a composite particle and the sum of the masses of its parts and the binding energy released during nuclear fusion? If I wanted to calculate the binding energy released during the proton-proton chain reaction, would I simply plug in 938.272 MeV for ##m_p##, 939.5654 MeV for ##m_n##, 2 for ##Z##, 2 for ##A-Z## (4 total nucleons minus 2 protons for a helium atom), and 3727.379 MeV for ##m_{nuc}##? This gives me 28.2958 MeV. Multiplying that by (3 x 10^8 m/s)^2 gives me 2.54662 x 10^18. Is this correct? Is that the energy released during a nuclear fusion reaction in a main sequence star?

If it helps to know, I took both calculus-based E&M (level of Purcell) and multi-variable calculus/vector calculus last semester. I have not taken university-level chemistry yet.

Thanks, guys!
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
Amrator said:
This gives me 28.2958 MeV. Multiplying that by (3 x 10^8 m/s)^2 gives me 2.54662 x 10^18. Is this correct? Is that the energy released during a nuclear fusion reaction in a main sequence star?
The first part is (roughly that many MeV), but you shouldn't multiply that by c^2 - MeV is already a unit of energy. I.e., the values you used are not in MeV, but in the convenient mass units of MeV/c^2. If you multiply a mass of 1 MeV/c^2 by c^2 you get 1 MeV of energy.

(Or you can just forget about mass altogether and use units of energy from start to finish)
 
  • Like
Likes D H
Amrator said:
This gives me 28.2958 MeV. ... Is that the energy released during a nuclear fusion reaction in a main sequence star?
@Bandersnatch already caught your big error, what was not using units correctly. The answer to the highlighted question is no. Some of that binding energy represents two protons becoming two neutrons. An easy way to get the correct answer is to look at what the system starts and ends with. The proton-proton chain changes four protons and two electrons into an alpha particle. Add the numbers up and you get 26.731 MeV rather than 28.2958 MeV.
 
  • Like
Likes Bandersnatch
This thread is dedicated to the beauty and awesomeness of our Universe. If you feel like it, please share video clips and photos (or nice animations) of space and objects in space in this thread. Your posts, clips and photos may by all means include scientific information; that does not make it less beautiful to me (n.b. the posts must of course comply with the PF guidelines, i.e. regarding science, only mainstream science is allowed, fringe/pseudoscience is not allowed). n.b. I start this...
Asteroid, Data - 1.2% risk of an impact on December 22, 2032. The estimated diameter is 55 m and an impact would likely release an energy of 8 megatons of TNT equivalent, although these numbers have a large uncertainty - it could also be 1 or 100 megatons. Currently the object has level 3 on the Torino scale, the second-highest ever (after Apophis) and only the third object to exceed level 1. Most likely it will miss, and if it hits then most likely it'll hit an ocean and be harmless, but...
Back
Top