Finding 'a' when 'x' is given as a function of 't'.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Noob245
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Function
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around finding the acceleration of a particle given its position as a function of time, expressed as x^2 = t^2 + 1. The user initially attempts to derive the acceleration by double differentiating the position function but struggles with the algebra and differentiation steps. Participants emphasize the importance of using the chain rule and correctly applying the power rule for derivatives. The user requests clarification on their mistakes and the correct algorithm for solving the problem. The conversation highlights the need for detailed steps in calculus to avoid errors in differentiation.
Noob245
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hello everyone! I have this question given to me by a friend and the question is:
Position of a particle x is given by x^2=t^2 + 1, t is time in second, find acceleration for time t.

So this is what I decide to do:
x^2 = t^2+1
so
x = sqrt(t^2+1)
if you double differentiate the function on RHS
You get:
(t^2+1)^-3/2 or 1/(t^2+1)^3/2

I'd be grateful if you give me the steps for finding the answer (including the steps for finding out the derivative, because I used an online calculator).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Noob245 said:
Hello everyone! I have this question given to me by a friend and the question is:
Position of a particle x is given by x^2=t^2 + 1, t is time in second, find acceleration for time t.

So this is what I decide to do:
x^2 = t^2+1
so
x = sqrt(t^2+1)
if you double differentiate the function on RHS
You get:
(t^2+1)^-3/2 or 1/(t^2+1)^3/2

I'd be grateful if you give me the steps for finding the answer (including the steps for finding out the derivative, because I used an online calculator).

Are you saying you don't know how to determine the derivative of the right hand side? If not, show us how you get the first derivative?
 
Chestermiller said:
Are you saying you don't know how to determine the derivative of the right hand side? If not, show us how you get the first derivative?

No, I do not know how. :(
 
It's the standard derivation of a function... hint: think how you can express roots as powers and think what the derivative of a power is...
Good work
 
Noob245 said:
No, I do not know how. :(
Have you had calculus yet?
 
Yes; I tried double differentiating it but my answer didn't match the one given in the calc. the answer I got was

-1/(t^2+1)^-3/2

This mistake is all the more reason I want the steps. I know that if you double differentiate 'x' I get 'a' but for some reason by answer does not even come close to the original answer. It'd be really kind of you guys if you could just tell me if I was correct or wrong, and if wrong where I went wrong and how I should proceed further.
 
Have you heard of the chain rule?
 
Noob245 said:
Yes; I tried double differentiating it but my answer didn't match the one given in the calc. the answer I got was

-1/(t^2+1)^-3/2

This mistake is all the more reason I want the steps. I know that if you double differentiate 'x' I get 'a' but for some reason by answer does not even come close to the original answer. It'd be really kind of you guys if you could just tell me if I was correct or wrong, and if wrong where I went wrong and how I should proceed further.
From this answer, it just looks like all you did was make a mistake in algebra. So us the details so we can see if we can spot it.

chet
 
GUYS GUYS! Forget about the calculus, please tell me if the algorithm I gave for sum is correct or not? If not, tell me the correct algorithm and the solution so I can try it out and match my answer.
 
  • #10
What algorithm?

How about you try the first derivative first?
##x = \sqrt{t^2 + 1}## - what is dx/dt? You are right that the derivative of ##\sqrt{u} = u^{\tfrac12}## is ##\tfrac12 u^{-\tfrac12} = \frac{1}{2 \sqrt{u}}##. But as the square root is over t² + 1, not u, you will need the chain rule like SteamKing said.
 
  • #11
Noob245 said:
GUYS GUYS! Forget about the calculus, please tell me if the algorithm I gave for sum is correct or not? If not, tell me the correct algorithm and the solution so I can try it out and match my answer.

You didn't give any detail about what you did... haw are we supposed to know where and why and what you did wrong?
 
Back
Top