First law of Thermodynamics and energy conservation

AI Thread Summary
The discussion clarifies the First Law of Thermodynamics, emphasizing energy conservation in different types of systems. In an isolated system, where no work (W) or heat (Q) is exchanged, the internal energy (ΔU) remains constant. However, in open systems, where W and Q can be non-zero, ΔU can change, indicating that energy is not conserved in the same way. The example of a gas in a cylinder illustrates how work done on the system increases its energy, while the total energy remains constant when considering the entire closed system. The conversation reinforces the principle that energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transformed or transferred.
mcastillo356
Gold Member
Messages
639
Reaction score
348
Hi PF!
I don't understand the sentence: on one side says the energy is preserved, and, at the end, the total energy of the system will change if ##W## or ##Q## is added: ##\Delta{U}=Q+W##.
Greetings!
 
Science news on Phys.org
If a system is isolated, then ##W = Q = 0## and ##\Delta U = 0##, i.e. the energy of the system is constant. But if the system is not isolated, and ##W## and ##Q## are non-zero, then ##\Delta U## is not necessarily zero and the system energy not necessarily constant!
 
  • Like
  • Love
Likes vanhees71, Dale and mcastillo356
There is difference between a closed and an open system when law of conservation of energy is considered. If we have an open system, there are some resultant external forces acting on the system. If system is closed, there are no resultant external forces acting on the system.

Lets say we have a cylinder that is containing some volume V of the gas. The gas will be the (open) system in this example. If we push a piston, the volume V of the system will decrease. The piston had done work W on the system. By that, the energy of system (the gas) increased by exactly the amount of work that piston had done on the system.
If our (closed) system includes the gas, the piston and us, the total energy of the system will be the same before pushing the piston and after pushing the piston.

But, the total energy is the same in both cases: for open system the total energy is the energy of system + work done on the system. The work done on the system was not created from thin air. In example above we pushed the piston and for that we used some our internal energy.

I hope this helps. Sorry for bad English, I'm not native speaker :)
 
  • Like
  • Love
Likes mcastillo356 and vanhees71
Thank you very much, etotheipi, KMCv! Well, let's see if I understood: example of open system: me; boiling water without a lid. Closed system: a pressure cooker, just before the safety valve opens. Isolated system: a thermoflask (this is not true; it's slower, but it exchanges heat with its surroundings). In terms of energy, there is a law, first proposed and tested by Émile du Châtelet, witch states that energy cannot be created nor destroyed; only transferred or transformed.
KMCv, your post is very revealing: the difference between open and closed system is the same in thermodynamics and Newton's dynamics; and in your example of the cylinder containing gas, we can apply ##\Delta{U}=Q+W## the same if the system is open or closed.
ethoteipi, thank you very much for explaining the definition of isolated system: ##\Delta{U}=0=Q+W##. No work nor heat (neither mass) can pass to the system.
Greetings
 
  • Like
Likes KMCv
I'm happy that helped! :)
 
Thread 'Thermo Hydrodynamic Effect'
Vídeo: The footage was filmed in real time. The rotor takes advantage of the thermal agitation of the water. The agitation is uniform, so the resultant is zero. When the aluminum cylinders containing frozen water are immersed in the water, about 30% of their surface is in contact with the water, and the rest is thermally insulated by styrofoam. This creates an imbalance in the agitation: the cold side of the water "shrinks," so that the hot side pushes the cylinders toward the cold...
Back
Top