Fizeau's Exp: TRANSFORMING VELOCITIES to Explain

In summary, Fizeau's experiment in 1851 used two light beams traveling through a tube of moving water, and the results were in agreement with Fresnel's theoretical prediction. Nowadays, we can interpret this result using Einstein's transformation of velocities. The principle of relativity states that the speed of light is constant in a vacuum, but in a non-vacuum like water, its speed can vary depending on the frame of reference. The index of refraction, which tells us the speed of light in a medium's rest frame, can change in a moving medium due to length contraction. To find the speed of light in water in a moving frame, we can use the relativistic velocity addition formula.
  • #1
In 1851 Fizeau made a famous experiment which corroborated de Fresnel's drag coefficient of the luminiferous ether. In the experiment two light beams traveled through a tube of moving water (at 7cm per second), one moving against the water flow (let's called it beam A), and one for the water flow (beam B). Then, the two beams were detected at the same detector, making an interference patern. The results were in agreement with Fresnel's theorerical prediction. According to it, the velocities of each light beam must be:
[V][/B] = c/n + αv,
[V][/A] = c/n - αv,
where n is refraction index of the water, and α is the Fresnel's drag coefficient, equals to 1 - 1/n², v is the velocity of the water, and c is the velocity of light in vacuum.

Nowadays we can reinterpretate this experimental result with Einstein's transformation of velocities.
Let's consider two reference frames: the laboratory frame, and the water frame, moving in respect to the first. In the water frame the velocity of light is c/n. In the lab frame the velocity of light must be:
[c][/lab] = (c/n + v)/(1 - v/nc)
If we expand this expression and neglect terms of the order of (v/c)2 and higher, we obtain exactly the same results as predicted by Fresnel's theory.

Ok, so far so good.

But one may ask: "The principle of relativity teaches us that light moves with the same speed, no matter the frame of reference (lab frame, water frame, whatever). So, how can we explain the Fizeau's experiment?"
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Felipe Prado said:
But one may ask: "The principle of relativity teaches us that light moves with the same speed, no matter the frame of reference (lab frame, water frame, whatever). So, how can we explain the Fizeau's experiment?"
This statement is missing the often implicit but ultimately important "in vacuum". If you have a surrounding medium, such as water, its presence in itself breaks Lorentz invariance by singling out a particular frame (its rest frame) where the speed of light is isotropic.

Edit: Also, that is not the principle of relativity. It is the assumption that the speed of light in vacuum is an invariant quantity.
 
  • Like
Likes Felipe Prado
  • #3
In a vacuum, the speed of light is a constant for all observers, a constant we call c.

In a non-vacuum, such as water, the analysis is more complex. In the rest frame of the water, we can say that v = c/n, where v is the speed of light in the water, c is (as before) the speed of light in a vacuum, and n is the refractive index of the water. This equation is only valid in the rest frame of the water, however, it's not valid in general. We could in principle determine the correct description of the speed in light-in-water in moving water by applying the Lorentz transform, but it'd take a fair bit of math.
 
  • Like
Likes Felipe Prado
  • #4
Let me see if I'm getting it straight, guys.
If an observer at the lab mesures the refractive index of the moving water he/she will get a different value compared with the value that an observer in the water (which sees lab moving) measures? The contraction of the lengths make the density of the water and the refractive index change, so as the speed of light in the moving medium?
 
  • #5
Felipe Prado said:
Let me see if I'm getting it straight, guys.
If an observer at the lab mesures the refractive index of the moving water he/she will get a different value compared with the value that an observer in the water (which sees lab moving) measures? The contraction of the lengths make the density of the water and the refractive index change, so as the speed of light in the moving medium?
The index of refraction is a material property that tells you what the speed of the light in the medium is in the rest frame of the medium. It makes no sense to measure it in a moving medium.
 
  • #6
Maximum speed of interaction is called light speed because the light speed in vacuum is a familiar example. Light speed in media is out of it.
 
  • Like
Likes Sorcerer
  • #7
We can apply the formulae for relativistic velocity addition to find the velocity-of-light-in-water in a moving frame knowing the velocity-of-light-in-wanter in the water frame.

If we limit ourselves to one dimension of space (plus of course, time), we can use the simple form of the relativistic velocity addition law, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity-addition_formula.

If we have a frame moving with respect to the water at velocity u, then we can write the velocity-of-light-in-water in the moving frame, which we will denote by v' by using the formula

$$v \ominus u = \frac{v-u}{1 - \frac{u\,v}{c^2}}$$

with v = c/n to get

$$v' = \frac{\frac{c}{n}-u}{1- \frac{u}{n\,c} } = \frac{c-u\,n}{n - \frac{u}{c}}$$

We use a "relativisticx velocity subtraction" so that if u = c/n, the velocity-of-light in water, v', is zero.
 

What is Fizeau's Experiment?

Fizeau's Experiment was a scientific experiment conducted by French physicist Hippolyte Fizeau in 1849. It was designed to measure the speed of light in a moving medium, specifically water.

How did Fizeau's Experiment work?

The experiment involved a beam of light being split in two and sent in opposite directions through a moving water stream. The light beams were then recombined and the interference pattern was measured to determine any changes in the speed of light caused by the moving water.

What did Fizeau's Experiment discover?

Fizeau's Experiment showed that the speed of light is affected by the medium through which it travels. The speed of light was found to be slower in a moving medium compared to a stationary one.

How did Fizeau's Experiment contribute to our understanding of light?

Fizeau's Experiment provided evidence for the wave theory of light, as the interference pattern observed supported the idea of light being a wave. It also helped to explain the phenomenon of aberration, which is the apparent change in the position of a star due to the Earth's motion around the Sun.

How is Fizeau's Experiment relevant today?

Fizeau's Experiment is still relevant today as it paved the way for further research into the nature of light and its behavior in different mediums. It also contributed to the development of the theory of special relativity by Albert Einstein, which explains the relationship between space and time in the presence of objects moving at high speeds.

Suggested for: Fizeau's Exp: TRANSFORMING VELOCITIES to Explain

Back
Top