Force on a Pulley: Understanding Tension and Tangents

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on understanding the forces acting on a pulley when a string with tension is deflected by an angle. The tension force is represented as T, and the horizontal force from the tension is derived as Tsin(θ0) based on geometric principles, where the angle θ0 relates to the tangent of the string. Additionally, the force from the string tension is expressed as Tsin(Δθ/2) due to the geometry of the angles involved. The total force on the pulley is calculated as the sum of the two tension vectors, leading to the conclusion that the force is 2Tsin(θ). The conversation emphasizes the importance of geometric relationships in determining these forces.
user240
Messages
5
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I'm having trouble understanding an example given in K&K's Intro to Mechanics textbook.

'A string with tension ##T## is deflected through an angle ##\theta_0## by a smooth fixed pulley. What is the force on the pulley'.

I don't understand how (in the first picture) they got the horizontal force from the tension to be ##Tsin(\theta_0)##, unless the angle I've circled in red is somehow ##\theta_0## also. In which case, how would you prove that?

I also don't get how (second picture) they found the force from the string tension to be ##Tsin(\frac{\Delta\theta}{2})##.
 

Attachments

  • pulley1.png
    pulley1.png
    4 KB · Views: 639
  • pulley2.png
    pulley2.png
    21.4 KB · Views: 810
Physics news on Phys.org
user240 said:
I don't understand how (in the first picture) they got the horizontal force from the tension to be ##Tsin(\theta_0)##, unless the angle I've circled in red is somehow ##\theta_0## also. In which case, how would you prove that?

The string is tangent to the pulley ...
 
By ##\boldsymbol T_1## denote the tension force from above (in the first picture) and by ##\boldsymbol T_2## denote the tension force from below, ##|\boldsymbol T_2|=|\boldsymbol T_1|=T##. Thus the pulley expirences the force ##\boldsymbol T_1+\boldsymbol T_2##. This is just a sum of two vectors.
 
Orodruin said:
The string is tangent to the pulley ...

Could you please elaborate? I'm probably overlooking something very basic here but it's not obvious to me why the force from the rope is then given as ##2Tsin(\theta)##

zwierz said:
By ##\boldsymbol T_1## denote the tension force from above (in the first picture) and by ##\boldsymbol T_2## denote the tension force from below, ##|\boldsymbol T_2|=|\boldsymbol T_1|=T##. Thus the pulley expirences the force ##\boldsymbol T_1+\boldsymbol T_2##. This is just a sum of two vectors.

I'm not sure why the force happens to be ##2Tsin(\theta)## though.
 
The tension is tangential to the pulley (90 degrees ) thus the angle that vector T encloses with the vertical is θ : you can prove this by simple geometry ) the T cos( θ) component cancels out while the only force left is the sum of the two tension pointing inwards.The first image shows the small angle taken to be 2θ and therefore the angle is θ but the second one is considering an angle θ so it becomes θ/2.Both are showing a diffrent magnification on the string.However, if you integrate the force you get the same total force.(but with different limits in the integral ,(for the first one is from 0 to 90while the second one is 0 to 180,which you can prove ,is equivalent)
 
Last edited:
user240 said:
I'm not sure why the force happens to be 2Tsin(θ)2Tsin(\theta) though.
introduce a coordinate frame and expand the vectors in coordinates
 
user240 said:
it's not obvious to me why the force from the rope is then given as 2T sin(θ)
You asked two questions, the first re T sin(θ0), the second re T sin(Δθ/2).
Orodruin was answering tne first question. It's simple geometry. The radius makes angle θ0 to the horizontal. The radius is perpendicular to the tangent. So the tangent makes angle θ0 to the vertical.

In the second picture, the author considers a short arc of the circle subtending angle Δθ at the centre. She takes a radius in the middle of that and constructs the tangent at that point, as well as tangents at each end of the arc. Can you see that the tangents at the end each make angle Δθ/2 to the tangent in the middle?
 

Similar threads

Back
Top