The Role of Inertia in Friction and Acceleration

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the relationship between inertia, friction, and acceleration in a rolling ball. It clarifies that when a ball rolls without slipping on a level surface, the frictional force does not contribute to acceleration but rather maintains the ball's motion due to inertia. Participants note that if the ball is rolling at a constant velocity, the net force and acceleration are zero, consistent with Newton's second law. The conversation also distinguishes between static friction, which prevents slipping, and the role of inertia in maintaining motion. Ultimately, the key takeaway is that inertia, not friction, is responsible for the ball's continued rolling on a horizontal surface.
RingNebula57
Messages
56
Reaction score
2
We know that when a ball is rolling ( just rolling no slipping) the frictional force is orientated in the direction of motion.
Why isn't the ball accelerating due to frictional force, if it is the only force in the motion direction?

To me it's quite daunting
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It is accelerating, its just that the acceleration is negative and opposes motion (commonly known as deceleration).
 
RingNebula57 said:
We know that when a ball is rolling ( just rolling no slipping) the frictional force is orientated in the direction of motion.

Do we? You need to be clear what you mean by frictional force. What frictional force is there if the ball is rolling along at a constant velocity?

Perhaps you mean rolling resistance?
 
phys.jpg

Ff is the friction force that's making the ball roll. If Ff is the only force acting upon the ball in the horizontal direction and the ball rolles in the Ff direction, than shouldn't the ball accelerate ( not decelarate, but go on and on )
 
RingNebula57 said:
[ ATTACH=full]85132[/ATTACH]
Ff is the friction force that's making the ball roll. If Ff is the only force acting upon the ball in the horizontal direction and the ball rolles in the Ff direction, than shouldn't the ball accelerate ( not decelarate, but go on and on )
Is the ball on a level horizontal surface?
 
SammyS said:
Is the ball on a level horizontal surface?
yes
 
RingNebula57 said:
yes
If the ball is rolling on a level horizontal surface and is continuing to roll at a steady rate then there is no sense in which we can say that friction is "making it roll". If anything, inertia is "making it roll".

The force of friction is zero and the ball has zero acceleration. This is consistent with Newton's second law. F = ma. 0 = 0.
 
  • Like
Likes SammyS
jbriggs444 said:
If the ball is rolling on a level horizontal surface and is continuing to roll at a steady rate then there is no sense in which we can say that friction is "making it roll". If anything, inertia is "making it roll".

The force of friction is zero and the ball has zero acceleration. This is consistent with Newton's second law. F = ma. 0 = 0.
If the force of friction was 0 than why is the ball rolling? Why isn't it just slipping ( like on ice) ?
 
RingNebula57 said:
If the force of friction was 0 than why is the ball rolling? Why isn't it just slipping ( like on ice) ?

If a ball is already rolling and it rolls onto ice (smooth, frictionless surface), then it will continue to roll.

If the ball is rolling on a rough surface it is essentially static friction. The point of the ball that touches the ground is not moving (instantaneously at rest), so the frictional force does no work. Just as it would if the ball was not moving.
 
  • Like
Likes CWatters
  • #10
RingNebula57 said:
If the force of friction was 0 than why is the ball rolling? Why isn't it just slipping ( like on ice) ?

What PeroK said.

The ball has inertia (eg a moment of inertia).
If it's already rolling when it encounters the ice it will keep rolling (nothing to stop it rolling)
If it's not rolling (eg it's sliding) when it encounters the ice it will keep sliding (nothing to make it start rolling)
 
Back
Top