Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around generating basis set files for the TURBOMOLE program and the challenges faced when attempting to create molecular orbitals from dummy atoms. Participants explore the syntax for basis set files, the implications of using dummy atoms without nuclear charges, and the feasibility of simulating unphysical scenarios in computational chemistry.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant seeks guidance on generating basis set files for TURBOMOLE, specifically for fitting Gaussian orbitals to dummy atoms.
- Another participant provides a detailed example of the syntax for a 6-31G basis set for carbon, explaining the structure and components of the basis set file.
- A participant reports success in creating a basis file that TURBOMOLE accepts but encounters issues generating molecular orbitals due to the absence of electrons in their configuration.
- Concerns are raised about the feasibility of performing calculations without any nuclear charges, with one participant questioning the goal of such an approach.
- One participant clarifies their aim to create free electrons without atomic nuclei, likening it to a particle in a box, and expresses interest in the resulting molecular orbitals despite the unphysical nature of the setup.
- Another participant argues that without a potential, there can be no bound states or molecular orbitals, suggesting that the software may not be suitable for this type of calculation.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the feasibility of generating molecular orbitals in the absence of nuclear charges. While some acknowledge the unphysical nature of the scenario, others question whether the approach can yield meaningful results.
Contextual Notes
Participants note that the calculations may not converge due to the lack of nuclear charges and the unconventional setup, highlighting the limitations of the TURBOMOLE software in handling such scenarios.