Help me remember a sci-fi book

In summary, a book called "Forbidden Planet" is about a future in which people take pills to reduce the population. Some of the pills contain a poison, and the story follows a group of people as they try to find out if they're going to die.
  • #1
lisab
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2,026
623
Not sure why this book has been knocking around in my memory for a few weeks. I read it ~25 years ago, the details are very sketchy.

The setting is Earth, sometime in the future. The world is faced with severe overpopulation, but there's a plan to reduce the population. Everyone will take a pill, and some portion of the pills are poison. The poison pills are randomly distributed, so you don't know if you were going to die or not.

Then I really don't know what happened!

Does this ring a bell to anyone?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Not ringing any bells with me, Lisa, but I've posted on a book-geek site asking if anyone there can bring it to mind. I'll let you know if I find out anything.

And, don't you just hate it when stuff like this is on the tip of your brain and you can't pry it loose? It's like Dave's falling box.
 
  • #3
GeorginaS said:
Not ringing any bells with me, Lisa, but I've posted on a book-geek site asking if anyone there can bring it to mind. I'll let you know if I find out anything.

And, don't you just hate it when stuff like this is on the tip of your brain and you can't pry it loose? It's like Dave's falling box.
Couldn't find Lisa's book through Google but, now you've got me wondering what Dave's falling box is. :confused:
 
  • #4
Everyone will take a pill, and some portion of the pills are poison. The poison pills are randomly distributed ..

This sounds like a fascinating story line. Hope someone tracks down the name of the book. I wouldn't mind reading it.
 
  • #5
lisab said:
Not sure why this book has been knocking around in my memory for a few weeks. I read it ~25 years ago, the details are very sketchy.

The setting is Earth, sometime in the future. The world is faced with severe overpopulation, but there's a plan to reduce the population. Everyone will take a pill, and some portion of the pills are poison. The poison pills are randomly distributed, so you don't know if you were going to die or not.

Then I really don't know what happened!

Does this ring a bell to anyone?
Hmm..I remember a short story built around the same principle:

In the future, one lives in a socialist state, and all inhabitants are required to drive on holiday at designated sites.
Along the route, everyone must pass through a tunnel; which will close off at some time, injecting poison gas into the tunnel.

The scheme has been used a number of times, I think..
 
  • #7
Does anyone know of a sci-fi book on time travel containing the phrases "somewhen," "anywhen," "nowhen," etc., (symmetrical with "somewhere," "anywhere," etc.)? Heinlein?

Does anyone remember a sci-fi novel of interstellar travel in a huge ship, which lasts for generations, and the descendants -- except a few "dangerous misfits" -- come to see their ship as the entire universe?
 
Last edited:
  • #8
EnumaElish said:
Does anyone know of a sci-fi book on time travel containing the phrases "somewhen," "anywhen," "nowhen," etc., (symmetrical with "somewhere," "anywhere," etc.)? Heinlein?

Does anyone remember a sci-fi novel of interstellar travel in a huge ship, which lasts for generations, and the descendants -- except a few "dangerous misfits" -- come to see their ship as the entire universe?

I think I've read more than one which fits each category. In both cases, they were "golden age" books rather than modern ones.

The second is probably Robert Heinlein's "Orphans of the Sky".

I'm not sure about the first; I think it's more likely to be Silverberg than Heinlein, although Asimov also uses similar terms in "End of Eternity".
 
  • #9
All 3 concepts have been done to death. That is not to say that any or all examples are bad. It's simply that there is no such thing as a new idea; every author, however, approaches the subject in a different way that makes the work unique. For instance, "Forbidden Planet" was based upon "The Tempest"; Star Trek's "Conscience of the King" upon "King Lear", etc.. The best example that I've seen was an anthology wherein one of the big Golden Age authors (Poul Anderson, I think) commissioned nearly a dozen writers to each provide a short story based upon a fellow of a particular name leaving home one day for a visit to the local euthanasia clinic. They were all so different that I read the whole collection from front to back with absolutely no sense of "rerun".
Here's a starting point for Enuma's inquiry. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsewhen" There are also "Paths to Otherwhere" and "Voyage From Yesteryear" by James P. Hogan, which might be candidates for such a vague question.
I agree that "Orphans of the Sky" is likely the most-read novel regarding a generation ship. (If you vaguely remember a two-headed dwarf named Bobo, then it's definitely the one.) There was also Harlan Ellison's "Phoenix Without Ashes". It was published in an anthology, but was actually a screenplay and was printed in that format. The script was bastardized into the awful, but still watchable, "The Starlost" TV series. Ellison was so appalled at the result that he demanded to be credited as "Cordwainer Bird" rather than under his real name.
I haven't a clue about the original question, but Andre's response is quite solid. The basic premise has been used repeatedly, including in such books as "Logan's Run".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #10
I've heard of several books, all with a similar premise. Their titles escape me. Can you remember anything else about the book? I agree with the others, this seems like a very interesting storyline.

Danger said:
All 3 concepts have been done to death.
Pun?
 
Last edited:
  • #11
Lancelot59 said:
Pun?

Yes, but I didn't realize it until you asked. :redface:
 
  • #12
Okay, so, Lisa, I copied your question and posted it on a book-geek site. They're generally good at identifying obscure lit stuff. I've only got one response so far to your question and she said, "No, I haven't heard of it. But I'd love to read it!"

I'll keep waiting. :smile:
 

1. What is the title of the sci-fi book?

The title of the book is usually the first piece of information that readers want to know. It is the main identifier of the book and can give clues about the genre and plot.

2. Who is the author of the book?

The author is the person who wrote the book. Knowing the author can help readers find other books they may enjoy if they liked the sci-fi book in question.

3. What is the plot of the book?

The plot is the main storyline of the book. It includes the setting, characters, conflicts, and resolution. Knowing the plot can help readers determine if the book is one they would be interested in reading.

4. When was the book published?

The publication date can give readers an idea of when the book was written and what historical or cultural context it may have. It can also help readers determine if it is a newer or older book.

5. Can you provide any memorable quotes or scenes from the book?

Readers may want to know specific quotes or scenes from the book to help jog their memory or to see if they have read the book before. It can also give them a taste of the writing style and themes of the book.

Similar threads

  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
2
Replies
44
Views
5K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
24
Views
8K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
8
Views
8K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
1
Views
4K
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
801
Back
Top