Help needed Analyzing a real op amp with both positive and negative feedback

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
5 replies · 6K views
Rio20
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hi
this is my first subject in this forum and i hope you can help
1.we have been given an assignment to analyze this non-ideal op amp with both positive and negative feedback and to be honest i don't even know where to start


i know i should post an attempt of trying to solve but honestly i don't know how to ,, so please give me hints or ideas and i will go through them

thanks forum
 

Attachments

  • Probelm.jpg
    Probelm.jpg
    35.1 KB · Views: 1,451
on Phys.org
Rio20 said:
Hi
this is my first subject in this forum and i hope you can help
1.we have been given an assignment to analyze this non-ideal op amp with both positive and negative feedback and to be honest i don't even know where to start


i know i should post an attempt of trying to solve but honestly i don't know how to ,, so please give me hints or ideas and i will go through them

thanks forum

Welcome to the PF.

Is there more to the question? What are the initial conditions of the circuit? Is there some Vi(t) somewhere, or just the circuit?

And what is the 1uF cap doing on the output of the "equivalent circuit" on the right?
 
It's going to oscillate with a frequency determined by the pot.

Ignore the positive feedback and consider the negative. Draw the circuit as an ideal OpAmp with a capacitor on the output. You'll see that the OpAmp charges the cap to a point where the output flips and then reverses so that the cap is discharging.

The positive feedback determines the trip points and therefore the frequency.
 
berkeman said:
Welcome to the PF.

Is there more to the question? What are the initial conditions of the circuit? Is there some Vi(t) somewhere, or just the circuit?

And what is the 1uF cap doing on the output of the "equivalent circuit" on the right?

thnx for welcoming me berkema :D .

there is no Vi(t) and the equivalent circuit is drawn next to it ,, we asked asked to analyze the following op amp in a non ideal way and get the voltage that will be on the capacitor and draw it ,,, it's more like an really very very complex RC circuit
 
Antiphon said:
It's going to oscillate with a frequency determined by the pot.

Ignore the positive feedback and consider the negative. Draw the circuit as an ideal OpAmp with a capacitor on the output. You'll see that the OpAmp charges the cap to a point where the output flips and then reverses so that the cap is discharging.

The positive feedback determines the trip points and therefore the frequency.

thnx antiphon and i think i got ur point ,, but can u show me some equations so i can fully understand ur point and thnx
 
Rio20 said:
thnx antiphon and i think i got ur point ,, but can u show me some equations so i can fully understand ur point and thnx

Sorry I can't take the time to work it out.

Assume that the output is clamped to the power supply levels when the inputs are not balanced. This simplifies your analysis to an RC circuit and the voltage dividers on the inputs.

The OpAmp will act like a comparator.