# Help with commutator question please!

#### jus8727

consider a general one dimensional potential v(x) drive an expression for the commutator [H,P] where h is hamiltonian operator and momentum operator. i keep getting zero and i dont think i should. since next part of hw question sais what condition must v(x) satisfy so that momentum will be constant of the motion recall that this is true if the momentum communtes with the hamiltonian. so i dont think it should zero. any help would be great trtying to do all hw problems to prepare for final!

Related Advanced Physics Homework News on Phys.org

#### samalkhaiat

$$[P^{2}/2m + V(x) , P] = [ V , P] = -i \frac{dV}{dx}$$

#### jus8727

thats how i started but didnt arrive at that can u show a little bit more detail if u dont mind.
thanks alot though

#### Count Iblis

Consider the action of the commutator on a wavefunction

[H, P] psi(x)

(so, we work in the position representation). Write out the commutator explicitely:

H P psi - P H psi

#### jus8727

yes thats what im doing but im still getting zero

#### phsopher

Expand the potential as a Taylor series and use the commutation relation $$[x,p]=i \hbar$$.

#### samalkhaiat

$$[P^{2}/2m + V(x) , P] = [ V , P] = -i \frac{dV}{dx}$$
$$[P^{2}/2m, P] + [V , P] = [V,P]$$

because [P,P] = 0.

then

$$[H,P] \phi(x) = [V(x) , id/dx] \phi(x) = iV \frac{d \phi}{dx} -i\frac{d}{dx} \{V(x)\phi(x)\} = \{-i dV/dx\} \phi(x)$$

#### jus8727

um is there an easier way? like the first respnse seems right but idk how to get there its an elementary problem that i have im sure

#### jus8727

samal where is the h bar term? is that a property of commutator i have never seen that before

#### jus8727

i think the problem is i dont know what to do when we have an additon in the commutator i dont know how to treat it

#### phsopher

The commutator is linear [A+B,C] = [A,C] + [B,C]. Just write it out and you'll see that.

#### samalkhaiat

samal where is the h bar term? is that a property of commutator i have never seen that before
I always set my h bar equal to 1. you can put it back in the equation. The first point you need to know is

[A + B , C] = [A,C] + [B,C]

the second point, an (differential) operator in the commutator acts on all the stuff on the right, so

$$[A , i\hbar d/dx] f(x) = A(i\hbar df(x)/dx) - i\hbar (d/dx)(Af(x))$$

#### jus8727

oh got it thanks alot guys!

### Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving