How Do You Solve a Differential Equation Using an Ansatz?

  • #1
Hamiltonian
296
193
Homework Statement
Take the ##ans\ddot atz## ##x(t) = At cos(ω_{0}t) + Btsin(ω_{0}t)## and adjust the constants ##A, B##
to solve the DE bellow in the case ##ω = ω_0##.
$$\ddot x + {\omega_0}^2 x=cos(\omega t)$$
Relevant Equations
-
Finding the first and second derivative of out ansatz, $$\dot x(t)=A(cos(\omega_0 t) - t\omega_0 sin(\omega_0 t)) + B(sin(\omega_0 t) + t\omega_0 cos(\omega_0 t))$$ $$\ddot x= A(-2\omega_0 sin(\omega_0 t) - t{\omega_0}^2cos(\omega_0 t)) + B(2\omega_0 cos(\omega_0 cos(\omega_0 t) -t{\omega_0}^2sin(\omega_0 t)))$$
The differential Equation we are trying to find a solution to is, $$\ddot x + {\omega_0}^2 x = cos(\omega_0 t)$$
if we plug in ##\dot x## and ##\ddot x## and after a little simplification we end up with, $$2\omega_0(Bcos(\omega_0 t) - Asin(\omega_0 t)) = cos(\omega_0t)$$
From here we essentially guess A and B such that the LHS=RHS, I can't think of any possible values that could satisfy the equation.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I didn't check every step in the algebra, but I see A and B that satisfy the last equation.
 
  • Like
Likes PeroK
  • #3
Hill said:
I didn't check every step in the algebra, but I see A and B that satisfy the last equation.
I initially thought of $$A=sin(\omega_0 t)$$ and $$B=cos(\omega_0 t)$$ using the trig identity, ##cos(2\theta) = cos^2(\theta)-sin^2(\theta)## we get,
$$2\omega_0 cos(2\omega_0 t) = cos(\omega_0 t)$$
but even this doesn't work.
 
  • Wow
Likes Delta2 and PeroK
  • #4
Hamiltonian said:
I initially thought of $$A=sin(\omega_0 t)$$ and $$B=cos(\omega_0 t)$$ using the trig identity, ##cos(2\theta) = cos^2(\theta)-sin^2(\theta)## we get,
$$2\omega_0 cos(2\omega_0 t) = cos(\omega_0 t)$$
but even this doesn't work.
A and B are constants!
 
  • #5
Hamiltonian said:
##2\omega_0(Bcos(\omega_0 t) - Asin(\omega_0 t)) = cos(\omega_0t)##
The above has to be true for all values of the variable t, so it should be clear that the absence of a ##\sin(\omega_0 t)## term on the right side has an effect on that term on the left side.
 
  • #6
Mark44 said:
The above has to be true for all values of the variable t, so it should be clear that the absence of a ##\sin(\omega_0 t)## term on the right side has an effect on that term on the left side.
Are you implying, ##A=0## and ##B=\frac{1}{2\omega_0}##

Edit: I shall not show my face around these parts of town henceforth.
 
  • Like
Likes PeroK and Delta2

FAQ: How Do You Solve a Differential Equation Using an Ansatz?

What is an ansatz in the context of differential equations?

An ansatz is an educated guess or an assumed form for the solution of a differential equation. It is based on the problem's characteristics and often incorporates known solutions of similar problems. The ansatz simplifies the process of finding a solution by reducing the problem to determining the parameters or functions within the assumed form.

How do you choose an appropriate ansatz for a differential equation?

Choosing an appropriate ansatz often relies on experience, intuition, and the nature of the differential equation. Common strategies include looking at the boundary conditions, symmetries, and the behavior of the equation at infinity or other critical points. Familiarity with solutions to similar equations can also guide the choice of ansatz.

Can you provide an example of using an ansatz to solve a differential equation?

Sure. Consider the simple first-order linear differential equation \( \frac{dy}{dx} + y = e^x \). A common ansatz for such equations is \( y = Ae^x \) where \( A \) is a constant. Substituting this into the differential equation, we get \( A e^x + Ae^x = e^x \), which simplifies to \( 2Ae^x = e^x \). Solving for \( A \), we find \( A = \frac{1}{2} \). Thus, the solution is \( y = \frac{1}{2}e^x \).

What if the initial ansatz does not work?

If the initial ansatz does not lead to a solution, it may need to be modified. This could involve adding additional terms, considering different functional forms, or re-evaluating the assumptions made. Sometimes, multiple ansätze might need to be tested before finding one that works.

Are there limitations to using an ansatz in solving differential equations?

Yes, there are limitations. An ansatz may not always lead to a solution, especially if the guess is not well-suited to the problem. Additionally, the method heavily relies on the solver's intuition and experience, which might not always be accurate. In some cases, more systematic or numerical methods might be required to find a solution.

Back
Top