How Do You Solve These Complex Math Problems?

  • Thread starter Thread starter schattenjaeger
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Load
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving complex math problems involving chain rules and differentials. The first problem involves finding dx/dy for the equations x=y*z and y=2sin(y+z), with participants suggesting the use of implicit differentiation and clarifying the roles of variables. The second problem focuses on using differentials with the thin lens formula to find the image distance when the object distance changes slightly. Participants emphasize the importance of treating the focal length as a constant while varying the other parameters. The conversation also touches on maximizing the area of a trapezoid formed by bending a material, highlighting the need for expressing the area in terms of relevant variables and applying calculus techniques.
schattenjaeger
Messages
176
Reaction score
0
First one up is a chain rule problem
x=y*z and y=2sin(y+z), find dx/dy. I've never seen a chain rule problem set up like that before and it's driving me insane. I've done all kinds of solving for various variables and subbing, and I can't get the right damned answer(which I do know from the book, at least)

Then there's a differential problem
the thin lens formula is 1/i +1/o =1/f

if i=15 when o=10, use differentials to find i when o=10.1

Again, it's different from all the others ones and it bugs me. do I go ahead and solve for f and am I assume f is the same or something for the +.1 case?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
yup, it's dx/dy
 
schattenjaeger said:
First one up is a chain rule problem
x=y*z and y=2sin(y+z), find dx/dy.

Are those two equations supposed to be a system? If so then I would eliminate z in the second one and subsitute in into the first.
 
Eliminating z is what I tried first, except the answer in the book is z-y+tan(y+z)
 
OK, one other question: Are you familiar with partial derivatives?
 
Yah

that's what this chapter is, in fact
 
OK. You've got a function x=f(y,z)=yz. What makes this weird is that in the chain rule you usually find dx/dt, where t is not the same as either of the two variables y or z. Only this time, it is.

So the Chain Rule for your problem would be written as:

<br /> \frac{dx}{dy}=\frac{\partial f}{\partial y}\frac{dy}{dy}+\frac{\partial f}{\partial z}\frac{dz}{dy}

Note that all I've done is put "y" where "t" is would normally be. Give that a shot.
 
Last edited:
schattenjaeger said:
Again, it's different from all the others ones and it bugs me. do I go ahead and solve for f and am I assume f is the same or something for the +.1 case?

f is the focal length, and it is a constant for a given lens. It is i and o that vary. So yes, find out what the value of f is and use it for the next part of the problem. You have a function of a single variable, and you can use Calculus I methods on it.
 
Ok, thanks! That's what I figured for the second one but wasn't sure

back to the first one, so you end up with

z+y(1/2sqrt(1-y^2/4))? Does that simplify to the given answer?
 
  • #10
I did indeed get the answer that you posted, but I didn't get any square roots along the way.
 
  • #11
I don't even see HOW you could get a square root out of that!

x=y*z so
\frac{dx}{dy}= z+ y(\frac{dz}{dy}) and you can get \frac{dz}{dy} by using "implicit differentiation" on y=2sin(y+z).
 
  • #12
oh, haha, I solved for z and then took the derivative of some arcsin
 
  • #13
Ok, yet annooother question!

I'll spare you the nitty details of the word problem, but I've got a piece of material 24 cm long, and if you bend the ends up it makes a trapezoid, and I need to maximize the area of that trapezoid

so I guess I need to express the area in terms of two variables, then take the partial derivatives in terms of each, and set the two equations =0 and solve for the variables?
 
  • #14
You might have to lay the details on us. If all you have is a trapezoid, then there can be up to 5 independent variables by my count. Is anything else said about the trapezoid?
 
  • #15
Well you bend the sides of the line/string/whatever up by an angle theta on each side, so I was able to express the area in terms of w(the length of the side that got bent up)and and sins and cosines of theta
 
  • #16
schattenjaeger said:
Well you bend the sides of the line/string/whatever up by an angle theta on each side,

See there? You didn't say that before. The definition of a trapezoid does not require that the two nonparallel sides each make the same angle with the parallel bases.

I would let one base of the trapezoid rest on the x-axis, with its midpoint at the origin. Then I would write down coordinates for the vertices. Since the trapezoid will be symmetric about the y-axis, you'll have 3 independent variables (1 for each base and 1 for the height). The constraint that the total perimeter is 24 can be used to eliminate 1 variable, which brings you to 2.
 
Back
Top